lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Geography · Year 9

Managing flooding in Pontgwenlas: three options

The town of Pontgwenlas, the Afon Gwenlas, every person and every figure on this sheet are invented for practice. They are modelled on the kinds of choices real Welsh councils face.

Fact file: Pontgwenlas

The three options

Option A: Flood wallsOption B: Slow the flow upstreamOption C: Protect homes and move the most at risk
What happensConcrete walls and earth banks, 1.5 metres high, along 1.2 km of river through the town.Plant 80 hectares of woodland, build 200 small “leaky dams” of logs in streams, and re-wet 40 hectares of peat bog on Mynydd Gwenlas.Fit flood doors, barriers and raised electric sockets in 150 homes. Set up a text message flood warning system. Buy the 12 homes on Stryd y Bont that flood most often, help the families move elsewhere in town, and turn the land into a riverside wetland park.
Cost£6.5 million, plus £45,000 a year to maintain£1.8 million, including payments to 3 farms for land they can no longer graze£2.4 million
How many homes it protectsAll 180 homes and 40 businesses, in floods up to a 1 in 100 year floodLowers the flood peak in town by about 15%. Enough to keep about 70 homes dry.12 homes removed from risk. The other 138 still get some water in a big flood, but damage and clean-up costs fall by about two thirds.
How long it takes2 years to build. The main road is closed for 6 months.2 years to build, but 10 to 15 years before the trees and bog work fully1 year
Other effectsWalls block views of the river and the path to the riverside park. River water moves faster, so flooding in Rhydfelen could get worse. Making concrete releases carbon dioxide.New habitats for birds and insects. Woodland and peat store carbon. Cleaner water. 6 new local jobs looking after the land. Farmers lose some grazing.Families on Stryd y Bont lose their homes and neighbours. The new park gives wildlife space and room for floodwater. No effect on Rhydfelen.

What people say

WhoWhat they say
Menna Rowlands, owns a café on the High Street“I have been flooded twice. Each time I was closed for 4 months. Only a proper wall will stop it. My insurance has tripled.”
Dafydd Jenkins, sheep farmer on Mynydd Gwenlas“I would lose a third of my best grazing. The payment helps, but it will not keep the farm going for my children.”
Ceri Lloyd, Gwenlas Rivers Trust (a local charity)“Walls just push the problem downstream. Working with nature helps the whole valley, and it gets better every year as the trees grow.”
Tom Harries, lives on Stryd y Bont“My family has lived on this street for 3 generations. I do not want to move, but I cannot face another flood either.”
Siwan Parry, lives in Rhydfelen“Whatever Pontgwenlas does, please do not send the water down to us.”

The three pillars of sustainability

A sustainable decision meets people’s needs now without making life worse for people in the future or in other places.