lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Computer Science · Year 9

Should pupils use AI chatbots for homework? Viewpoints and word bank

The school, the people and their views on this sheet are invented. They are typical of views people hold. No real product is named.

1. The question

The school council at Ysgol Caerwenlli is writing a guide on homework. Year 9 have been asked to write a balanced answer to this question: “Should pupils be allowed to use AI chatbots for homework?” An AI chatbot is a program that answers questions in everyday language. It predicts a likely answer from patterns in huge amounts of text, which means it can be helpful but can also be wrong.

2. Viewpoints

WhoWhat they said
Cai, Year 9 pupil“When I’m stuck at 9 o’clock at night, there’s nobody to ask. A chatbot explains it in a different way, like a tutor, and I can ask it again and again without feeling silly.”
Ms Rees, Computer Science teacher“Chatbots can give answers that sound confident but are wrong. If pupils copy the answer, they learn nothing, and I can’t see what they really understand.”
Mr Owusu, parent“Not every family can pay for extra help. Some of these tools are free, so they could make things fairer. But I worry about what happens to what my daughter types into them.”
Mrs Hughes, school librarian“Pupils need to learn to check any answer against a reliable source, whether it comes from a website, a book or a chatbot.”
Deio, Year 11 pupil“Many AI tools have a minimum age in their rules, so younger pupils might not be allowed to use them anyway. You should check before you sign up.”

3. Connectives by job

JobConnectives
Adding a pointalso, furthermore, in addition, moreover
Contrastinghowever, on the other hand, although, whereas, despite
Cause and effectbecause, therefore, as a result, so, consequently
Giving an examplefor example, for instance, such as
Conditionif, unless, as long as
Concludingoverall, on balance, in conclusion, to sum up

4. Three types of sentence

TypeWhat it isExample
SimpleOne main clause: one subject and one verb.Chatbots can explain topics.
CompoundTwo main clauses joined by and, but, or or so. Each half makes sense on its own.Chatbots can explain topics, but they can be wrong.
ComplexA main clause and a subordinate clause that starts with a word such as although, because, if, unless or which. The subordinate clause does not make sense on its own.Although chatbots can explain topics, they can be wrong.

Tip: when a complex sentence starts with the subordinate clause, put a comma after it.

5. Ffion’s first draft

AI chatbots are good. They help you. They explain things. Teachers don’t like them. They can be wrong. And pupils copy. And they don’t learn anything. Some tools store what you type. That is bad. I think they should be allowed.