lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Science · Year 9
Both texts are invented for practice. The newspaper, the people, the account, the product and every figure marked “invented” are made up. The science in Text A and in the pharmacist’s reply is accurate. The claims in Ffion’s post are deliberately misleading.
The Menai Star (invented newspaper) · Health feature
A Bangor GP and a 14-year-old from Bethesda explain why the antibiotics in your bathroom cabinet matter more than you think.
[1] Last spring, Mair Hughes, 71, went into hospital for a new hip. The operation went well. Then the wound turned red, hot and swollen. “Nain had a temperature and she was so tired she could hardly speak,” says her grandson Osian, a Year 9 pupil from Bethesda. “We kept asking why the tablets weren’t working.”
[2] The answer was MRSA.
[3] MRSA is a type of Staphylococcus aureus bacterium that is resistant to several widely used antibiotics. These bacteria often live harmlessly on the skin and in the nose, but if they get into a wound they can cause a serious infection. Mair’s doctors had to switch to a different antibiotic, given through a drip, and she spent 3 extra weeks in hospital. She has now recovered.
[4] “Patients like Mrs Hughes are the reason I lose sleep,” says Dr Siân Pritchard, who has been a GP in Bangor for 18 years. “Antibiotic resistance is the most frightening thing I see in my job.”
[5] Antibiotics are medicines that kill bacteria or stop them from growing. Since Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin in 1928, they have saved millions of lives. But they have one great weakness. Bacteria change.
[6] Bacteria reproduce very quickly: in ideal conditions some can divide every 20 minutes. Each time a bacterium copies its DNA, there is a small chance of a random change called a mutation. Very occasionally, a mutation makes a bacterium resistant to an antibiotic. When that antibiotic is used, the ordinary bacteria are killed, but the resistant ones survive. With less competition, they multiply and pass the resistance on to the bacteria they produce. This is natural selection, and every unnecessary dose of antibiotics gives it another push.
[7] Dr Pritchard sees the problem every winter. “People come in with a cold or flu and ask for antibiotics. Colds and flu are caused by viruses, and antibiotics do not work on viruses. Taking them does nothing for the patient, but it gives resistant bacteria in their body another chance to win.” She estimates that about 1 in 4 people who ask her for antibiotics have a viral infection (invented figure).
[8] It is not only colds. Stopping a course of tablets early, or saving some for later, can leave the toughest bacteria alive. Sharing antibiotics means someone takes a medicine that may be wrong for their illness. Antibiotics are also used in farming, and using more than is needed gives resistant bacteria another place to develop, from where they can spread to people. “This is not one person’s choice,” says Dr Pritchard. “We all share the same bacteria.”
[9] So what happens if nothing changes? Before antibiotics, a cut from a garden thorn could lead to a deadly infection. Dr Pritchard does not want to go back. “We are sleepwalking towards a world where a scratched knee could kill,” she warns. “Scientists are searching for new antibiotics, but finding one takes many years, and bacteria do not wait.”
[10] Osian has changed his own habits. “I used to think the course on the label was more of a suggestion,” he admits. “Now I know you take them exactly how the doctor or pharmacist says, and you finish the course unless they tell you otherwise. And you never take someone else’s.” He and his school’s science club have designed posters for the surgery waiting room.
[11] Dr Pritchard’s advice is simple. If you have a cold, rest, drink plenty of fluids and ask a pharmacist about easing the symptoms. If you are prescribed antibiotics, take them exactly as the label says. Never share them, and take any leftovers back to a pharmacy. Wash your hands, because stopping an infection spreading means fewer antibiotics are needed in the first place.
[12] Mair is walking again, with a stick and a smile. “I was lucky,” she says. “The next person might not be. These medicines belong to all of us. Let’s not waste them.”
Ffion’s Wellness Life @ffionwellnesslife · 48,200 followers (invented) · Sponsored
Cold season is HERE, lovelies!! Here’s my secret. The second I feel a sniffle, I ask for antibiotics. Knocks a cold out in 2 days, every time! I only take them until I feel better and save the rest for next time. Gave half to my sister last week and she was fine by Friday. Doctors just don’t want you to know how easy it is! Honestly the best thing I’ve ever done for my health.
And if your GP says no, try my ImmunoMax drops: a 100% natural antibiotic that kills 99.9% of viruses AND bad bacteria. Use code FFION20 for 20% off! #NeverIll #WellnessWales #ad
2,314 likes (invented) · 2 replies shown
llinos_88: Tried it last winter, worked for me!!
Dewi Owen, Pharmacist: Please don’t do this. Colds are caused by viruses, and antibiotics do not work on viruses. Most colds get better on their own in about a week. Saving or sharing antibiotics helps resistant bacteria to develop. Ask your local pharmacist for advice on easing cold symptoms.