lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Science · Year 8

Testing thermal insulators: Class 8B’s method, repeat readings and physics notes

Ysgol Bryn Celyn and Class 8B’s repeat readings are invented for this lesson, but the cooling patterns and thermal conductivity values in Section 4 reflect real physics.

1: Class 8B’s investigation method

Investigation question: Which wrapping material is the best thermal insulator for keeping hot water warm inside a glass beaker?

Apparatus: Five identical 250 cm³ glass beakers, four wrapping materials (aluminium foil, corrugated cardboard, bubble wrap, and Welsh sheep’s wool fleece), elastic bands, five cardboard lids with a central hole for a digital thermometer, a measuring cylinder, a kettle, and a stopwatch.

  1. Leave Beaker A unwrapped as a control so you can compare wrapped beakers against bare glass.
  2. Wrap Beakers B, C, D and E in 2 layers (total thickness 6 mm) of their assigned material and hold the wrap tight with two elastic bands.
  3. Measure exactly 200 cm³ of hot water into a measuring cylinder, pour it into the beaker, and immediately place the cardboard lid on top.
  4. Wait until the digital thermometer reads exactly 80.0°C, then start the stopwatch.
  5. After 15 minutes, stir gently once and record the final water temperature to the nearest 0.5°C.
  6. Subtract the final temperature from 80.0°C to find the temperature drop (°C) over 15 minutes. Repeat the test 4 times for each beaker.

2: Raw table of 4 repeat temperature drops over 15 minutes

Every test started at exactly 80.0°C. A smaller temperature drop means less thermal energy escaped to the room, so the material is a better thermal insulator.

Beaker and wrapping material Repeat 1 drop (°C) Repeat 2 drop (°C) Repeat 3 drop (°C) Repeat 4 drop (°C) Group lab book note
Beaker A: No insulation (bare glass control) 32.5 31.5 32.0 32.0 Cardboard lid on for all 4 repeats.
Beaker B: Aluminium foil (2 layers, shiny metal) 28.0 27.5 28.5 28.0 Cardboard lid on. Foil felt very hot to touch on the outside.
Beaker C: Corrugated cardboard (fluted paper channels) 22.0 22.5 21.5 22.0 Cardboard lid on for all 4 repeats.
Beaker D: Bubble wrap (sealed plastic air pockets) 17.5 18.5 29.0 18.0 Mistake in Repeat 3: group left the cardboard lid off for the whole 15 minutes!
Beaker E: Welsh sheep’s wool fleece (crimped fibres) 12.0 12.5 11.5 12.0 Cardboard lid on. Outside of wool felt cool to touch.

3: Calculation rules

Calculation Formula and worked rule
Spotting and handling an anomaly An anomaly (or outlier) is a repeat reading that is far away from the other repeats for the same beaker, often caused by a mistake in the method. Circle the anomaly, leave it out when adding the repeats together, and divide by the number of remaining valid repeats (for example, divide by 3 instead of 4).
Mean temperature drop (°C) mean = sum of valid repeats ÷ number of valid repeats.
Example (Beaker A): (32.5 + 31.5 + 32.0 + 32.0) ÷ 4 = 128.0 ÷ 4 = 32.0°C.
Range of valid repeats (°C) range = highest valid reading − lowest valid reading. (A small range shows the repeats are close together and repeatable.)
Example (Beaker A): 32.5 − 31.5 = 1.0°C.
Final temperature (°C) final temperature = starting temperature (80.0°C) − mean temperature drop.
Example (Beaker A): 80.0 − 32.0 = 48.0°C.
Percentage heat loss from 80.0°C (%) percentage heat loss = (mean temperature drop ÷ starting temperature) × 100.
Example (Beaker A): (32.0 ÷ 80.0) × 100 = 40.0%.

4: Physics fact card: thermal conduction and trapped air