lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Design Technology · Year 10

Bocs Bwyd (Lunch Box): design review pack

The client, the brief, the 3 proposals, the test results, the costs and the council recycling rules are invented for this lesson. One pack per group. Each person reads the brief, the proposals and their own role card.

1. The brief

Client: Cegin Gymunedol Aberfelen (Aberfelen Community Kitchen), which runs a holiday lunch club for children aged 7 to 11.

Need: 500 reusable lunch boxes to replace single-use packaging. The box must:

  1. keep a sandwich, a piece of fruit and a snack apart;
  2. not leak when tipped on its side;
  3. be opened and closed by a 7-year-old without help;
  4. survive at least 100 dishwasher washes;
  5. carry the kitchen’s logo;
  6. cost no more than £4.50 per box to make (£2250 for 500);
  7. be recyclable at the end of its life.

2. The 3 proposals

Each proposal was tested by 8 children aged 7 to 11. For the leak test, each box was filled with yoghurt 10 times and left on its side for 1 hour. Costs include printing or engraving the logo (£0.15 per box).

 A: “Clip”B: “Dur” (steel)C: “Plyg” (fold)
What it isPolypropylene box, 3 moulded compartments, lid with a silicone seal and 4 small clipsStainless steel box, 2 compartments, stretch-on silicone lidFood-grade silicone box, 2 compartments, press seal, folds flat when empty
Cost per box£3.80£5.20£4.20
Leaks (out of 10)021
Opened without help5 of 8 children (3 of the 7-year-olds could not)8 of 88 of 8
After 100 washesNo changeLid slightly stretchedOrange stains from tomato sauce
Mass180 g320 g140 g
End of lifeBox and lid go in the kerbside collection. The seal must be pulled out and binned.Box goes in the kerbside metal collection. The silicone lid is binned.Not accepted in the kerbside collection. The maker will take boxes back for £0.30 each.
What children said“The clips hurt my fingers.” “My crisps didn’t get wet.”“It’s heavy in my bag.” “The lid came off when I dropped it.”“Squishy and fun.” “It went orange from my pasta.”

3. Role cards

Groups of 5 take one role each. In a group of 4, the Chair also takes the minutes.

Chair. You run the meeting but do not push your own view first. Follow the agenda and keep time. Invite every person to speak, especially quiet ones. Make sure at least 3 options are listed before anyone decides. Aim for agreement; if the group is stuck after 3 minutes, ask for a vote. End by asking the Minute-taker to read the decision back.

Client voice. You speak for Cegin Gymunedol Aberfelen. Your top priority: staff cannot open 500 boxes a day, so children must open them alone. The budget is fixed at £4.50 a box. The logo matters to your funders.

Engineer or Maker. Your top priority: the box must work reliably, so no leaks. You know these changes (cost per box): A with 2 large lever clips instead of 4 small ones: +£0.25, and all 4 of the 7-year-olds who tried it opened it. A without its seal: leaked 6 times out of 10. B in thinner steel: −£0.60, but dents easily. C with thicker walls to stop leaks: +£0.40.

Sustainability lead. Your top priority: what happens at the end of the box’s life. Ask how long each box will last, what can be recycled locally, and whether a heavier box that lasts longer is better than a lighter one that is binned. Remember that using a box many times is also a way to cut waste.

Minute-taker. You record, on the minutes template, who was present, the options discussed, the decision, at least 2 reasons, and any actions (who, what, by when). Record disagreement fairly. You may stop the meeting to ask, “Can I check what we have agreed?”

4. The agenda (20 minutes)

 ItemTime
1Chair: welcome, roles and the aim of the meeting1 min
2Opening views: each role speaks for up to 1 minute, with no interruptions5 min
3Each proposal against the 7 points of the brief8 min
4Options: choose one, change one, or combine features4 min
5Decision, reasons and actions; the Minute-taker reads them back2 min

5. Problem card (round 2 only: do not read until the cover teacher says)

Message from the client, 11:15. “Our grant has been cut. The most we can now pay is £4.00 per box. Also, parents have asked that every part of the box can go in the kerbside collection. Please review your decision and send us a revised recommendation.”