lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Integrated Science · Year 11

Hydrogen or bioethanol? Evidence cards for Cyngor Bro Cynon

The council, its buses and every cost on this sheet are invented. The science on the cards marked H1 to H4 and B1 to B5 is general scientific background and is accurate.

1. The decision

Cyngor Bro Cynon runs 40 diesel buses. Councillors want to cut the carbon dioxide the buses release and improve the air quality in the town centre. They have narrowed the choice down to two fuels: hydrogen in fuel cell buses, or bioethanol in converted engines. They have asked for a short written evaluation that reaches a decision.

2. Evidence cards: hydrogen fuel cell buses

CardEvidence
H1A fuel cell combines hydrogen with oxygen from the air to make electricity, which drives the bus. The only product at the exhaust is water.
H2Most hydrogen made in the world today comes from natural gas, a fossil fuel. Making it this way releases carbon dioxide.
H3Hydrogen can also be made by the electrolysis of water, using electricity from wind or solar power. This releases very little carbon dioxide, but it currently costs more.
H4Hydrogen is a very flammable gas. It must be stored under high pressure in strong tanks.
H5 (invented)There is no hydrogen filling station near Bro Cynon. Building one at the bus depot would cost about £2.5 million.
H6 (invented)Each hydrogen bus would cost about twice as much as a new diesel bus.

3. Evidence cards: bioethanol buses

CardEvidence
B1Bioethanol is made by fermenting sugars from crops such as sugar cane, maize or wheat.
B2Burning bioethanol releases carbon dioxide. However, the crops took in carbon dioxide from the air by photosynthesis while they were growing.
B3Growing, fertilising, harvesting and transporting the crops, and distilling the ethanol, all use energy, often from fossil fuels. So bioethanol is not completely carbon neutral.
B4Land used to grow fuel crops cannot grow food at the same time.
B5Burning any fuel in an engine still produces some air pollutants at the exhaust, such as nitrogen oxides.
B6 (invented)Each diesel bus could be converted for about £15,000. Fuel would be delivered by tanker to the existing depot.

4. Connectives: words that link ideas

JobExamples
Adding a pointfurthermore, in addition, also, moreover
Contrastinghowever, whereas, although, on the other hand, but
Cause and effectbecause, therefore, as a result, so, consequently, this means that
Comparingsimilarly, likewise, both, in the same way
Concludingoverall, on balance, to conclude, weighing this up

5. Three kinds of sentence

6. Tomos’s first attempt

Hydrogen buses only make water. Hydrogen is made from natural gas. Hydrogen is flammable. Bioethanol comes from crops. Crops take in carbon dioxide. Bioethanol makes carbon dioxide. Land is needed for food. I think hydrogen.