lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Maths · Year 9

The Caerwenlli Maths club claims board

The school, the club and the pupils on this sheet are invented. The maths is real.

1. The challenge

Every week, members of the Maths club at Ysgol Caerwenlli pin a claim to the noticeboard. This week Mr Pritchard, who runs the club, has added a sign: “Is it ALWAYS true, SOMETIMES true or NEVER true? Prove it.”

2. This week’s claims

No.Pinned byClaim
1Deio“If you add two odd numbers, the answer is even.”
2Anwen“Multiplying a number by another number makes it bigger.”
3Twm“If you add 3 consecutive whole numbers, the answer is a multiple of 3.”
4Lowri“n2 + n + 41 is a prime number for every whole number n. I tried n = 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 and got 43, 47, 53, 61 and 71. They are all prime, so it works for every number.”
5Gethin“A triangle can have two obtuse angles.”
6Megan“The angles inside a quadrilateral add up to 360°.”
7Siôn“Squaring a number makes it bigger.”
8Ela“If a number ends in 4, it is in the 4 times table.”

3. Words mathematicians use

WordMeaning
conjectureA statement you think is true but have not yet proved.
exampleOne case where the claim works. It supports a claim but does not prove it.
counterexampleOne case where the claim does not work. One counterexample is enough to show a claim is not always true.
proofAn argument that shows a claim is true for every case, not just the ones you tried.
consecutiveNext to each other in order, such as 7, 8, 9.
obtuseAn angle between 90° and 180°.

4. Tools for proof

Let n stand for any whole number. Any even number can be written as 2n. (2 × a whole number) Any odd number can be written as 2n + 1. (1 more than an even number) Two different odd numbers: 2a + 1 and 2b + 1. 3 consecutive whole numbers: n, n + 1, n + 2. A number is a multiple of 3 if you can write it as 3 × (a whole number).

Angle facts you may use: the angles in a triangle add up to 180°. A diagonal of a quadrilateral splits it into two triangles.

5. Mr Pritchard’s hints