lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Business · Year 10
Caffi’r Bont, Siân Rees, Pontglas, Aberbryn and every figure on this sheet are invented. The figures are realistic for a small café business.
Siân Rees runs Caffi’r Bont, a café beside the old stone bridge in Pontglas, a small town in the Cynon Valley (pont is Welsh for “bridge”). It is famous locally for breakfasts and for Welsh cakes baked fresh every morning in the café kitchen.
Siân is a sole trader. She employs 6 part-time staff. Last year the café made a profit of £24,000, and she has £12,000 saved in the business bank account. She wants to grow the business and has two options.
| Aim | What Siân says |
|---|---|
| 1 | “I want people all over the valley to know the Caffi’r Bont name, and I want the business to make more profit.” |
| 2 | “I will not borrow more than £10,000. I have seen too many cafés close because of debt.” |
| 3 | “My two children play sport on Saturdays. I want to keep my weekends for my family as much as I can.” |
| 4 | “Every Welsh cake must still be baked in my own kitchen. Quality is why people come back.” |
| Who | What they said |
|---|---|
| Bethan, Siân’s longest-serving member of staff | “I would love to run the van at weekends one day. I just need the insurance.” |
| The bank manager | “We can lend £20,000 for the café, but a new café often takes 2 years to build up its customers.” |
| Survey of 50 regular customers | 38 of the 50 said they would visit a Caffi’r Bont in Aberbryn. 41 of the 50 said they had bought food from a van at a local event in the last year. |
Siân must choose between Option A and Option B. Recommend which option she should choose. Justify your answer. [9 marks]
This mark scheme was written for this lesson. It is not a WJEC mark scheme, but it rewards the same things: using the case study, developing points and making a justified judgement.
| Level | What the answer does |
|---|---|
| Level 3 7 to 9 marks | Clear recommendation. Developed points about both options, each linked to the case study and Siân’s aims, using figures. Connectives show cause and effect. The conclusion weighs the options, says why the chosen one is better and what the decision depends on. |
| Level 2 4 to 6 marks | A recommendation with some developed points, some use of the case study and at least one figure. May be one-sided, or the conclusion repeats earlier points without weighing them. |
| Level 1 1 to 3 marks | Simple points that are listed, not developed. Little use of the case study. The recommendation has weak or no justification. |