lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · The Sciences · Year 11

Cai’s osmosis write-up: the first draft

Cai, his teacher and his results are invented. The practical is a standard osmosis practical. This is practice material only: it is not anyone’s NEA.

1. What the class did

Cai’s class investigated how the concentration of sucrose solution affects the change in mass of potato cylinders. The equipment and quantities the class used were:

percentage change in mass = (final mass − starting mass) ÷ starting mass × 100

2. Cai’s first draft

Osmossis practical

Aim: To see what happens to potato in sugar water.

Method: I cut some potato and wieghed it and put it in the tubes with the different sugars in and left them for a day then I weighed them again and worked out the change and I made sure it was a fair test.

Results:

ConcentraitionChange 1Change 2Change 3Mean
0.0+18.0+18.6+18.0+18.2
0.2+8.1+7.6+8.0+7.9
0.4−1.5−2.2−1.7−1.8
0.6−9.8+2.1−9.4−5.7
0.8−15.0−15.6−15.3−15.3
1.0−16.2−15.9−15.9−16.0

Conclusion: My reuslts show that the potato got bigger in the water because the water went in by osmossis and it got smaller in the sugar because the sugar sucked the water out. The more sugar the more it went down.

Evaluation: My results were quite accurate and it was a fair test. The cell membrane is partialy permable so it lets water through. To improve it I would do it more times and use better scales and keep the tubes seperate. There was one weird result.

3. Feedback from Cai’s teacher

“Cai, good results, but the write-up does not do them justice. Please redraft it using this checklist.”

  1. Accuracy: spell every scientific word correctly.
  2. Vocabulary: use precise scientific terms instead of everyday words.
  3. Method: numbered steps, with quantities, that someone else could follow exactly.
  4. Results: units in the headings, anomalies identified and left out of the mean.
  5. Conclusion: describe the pattern with numbers from the data, then explain it with the science.
  6. Evaluation: name specific problems and specific improvements, and say how each would help.

4. Word bank

TermMeaning
osmosisthe movement of water molecules from a dilute solution to a more concentrated solution through a partially permeable membrane
partially permeable membranea membrane that lets small molecules such as water through, but not larger molecules such as sucrose
independent variablethe variable you change (here, the concentration of sucrose)
dependent variablethe variable you measure (here, the percentage change in mass)
control variablesvariables kept the same so the test is fair, such as cylinder length, volume of solution and time
anomalous resulta result that does not fit the pattern of the others
repeatablethe same person using the same method gets similar results when they repeat it
resolutionthe smallest change a measuring instrument can show