dcf.cymru stimulus sheet · History · Year 9

Verifying Historical Photographs and Captions from the South Wales Coalfield

Keep this sheet beside your worksheet. Compare the 4 viral social media posts in Section 1 against the official archive catalogue cards in Section 2 and the copyright guide in Section 3.

1. Four Viral Social Media Posts

Each post below appeared on a social media feed this week. None of them links to an archive catalogue card.

Post ID Account and reach What the uploaded image shows Caption and text on the post
Post A @RealPastSnap
42,000 reposts
A brightly coloured image of men in flat caps standing in two lines outside a stone hall in Tonypandy. “Rare original colour photo of Tonypandy colliers cheering outside the pit after winning a pay rise in November 1910! No credit needed because I found it on Google Images.”
Post B @HistoryDailyUK
18,500 reposts
Four teenage boys holding safety lamps outside a brick building at a colliery surface. The bottom edge of the photo has been tightly cropped off. “Heartbreaking photo of 9-year-old child trappers working underground in a Rhondda pit during the 1926 General Strike. Cropped the ugly archive strip off the bottom for a clean look.”
Post C @VintageMerchStore
9,200 reposts
Black-and-white photograph of women in aprons peeling potatoes into large metal boilers outside a workmen’s hall. “1926 Maerdy Women’s Soup Kitchen Committee. Order this historic image printed on mugs (£14.99) and tote bags (£12.99) from our online gift shop today!”
Post D @ValleysNostalgia
27,400 reposts
Black-and-white street scene showing men in overcoats and boots carrying painted cloth banners down a terraced street in Aberdare. “Miners marching through Aberdare in 1919 celebrating the end of the First World War. Shared without credit.”

2. Official Archive Catalogue Cards

Archivists at three Welsh collections matched the 4 social media images to their original glass plates and negatives.

Archive Card 1 · Reference: CWM-1910-042 (matches Post A)

Archive Card 2 · Reference: CWM-1921-118 (matches Post B)

Archive Card 3 · Reference: CWM-1926-209 (matches Post C)

Archive Card 4 · Reference: CWM-1936-305 (matches Post D)

3. Quick Guide to Copyright, Provenance and Creative Commons

Term or code What it means for historians and digital publishers
Provenance The documented history of a source: who created it, when, where, and which archive holds the original. Without provenance, a photograph cannot be trusted as historical evidence.
UK copyright duration For photographs, copyright normally lasts for the creator’s lifetime plus 70 years from the end of the calendar year in which they died.
Public Domain Out of copyright. Anyone may copy or publish the work, though historians still give the archive reference so readers can verify the source.
BY (Attribution) You must credit the photographer, the archive collection, the reference code, and the licence.
NC (Non-Commercial) You must not use the image to make money or sell merchandise without permission from the rights holder.
ND (No Derivatives) You must not crop, recolour, paint over or edit the image. Only verbatim copies of the original are allowed.
SA (ShareAlike) If you remix or build upon the work, you must release your new work under the exact same Creative Commons licence.
AI colourisation Software guesses colours that were not recorded on the black-and-white negative. It can make a 1910 image look modern, but it is an interpretation, never an original colour record.

4. Museum Caption Formula (TASL + Historical Context)

When a museum or school website displays an archive photograph, the caption should include two parts:

  1. Historical explanation (1 to 2 sentences): state accurately who is shown, where and when the photograph was taken, and what historical event was taking place.
  2. Attribution line (TASL): Title (and archive reference) · Author (photographer) · Source (collection) · Licence (or Public Domain status, plus any alteration note).