lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Maths · Year 8

Explaining equations: connectives and pupils’ work

Rhian, Ioan and Megan are invented Year 8 pupils. Their mistakes are deliberate. The maths in sections 1 and 2 is correct.

1. Solving an equation

An equation is like a balance: whatever you do to one side, you must do to the other side. To find x, undo what has been done to it, using the inverse (opposite) operation: subtract to undo adding, add to undo subtracting, divide to undo multiplying and multiply to undo dividing.

3x + 5 = 20 3x = 15 (subtract 5 from both sides) x = 5 (divide both sides by 3) Check: 3 × 5 + 5 = 15 + 5 = 20

2. Connectives bank

Connectives link ideas and show how one step leads to the next.

JobConnectives
Sequence (order)First, Next, Then, After that, Finally
Cause (why)because, since, as
Result (what happens)so, therefore, this means that, which gives
Purpose (what for)in order to, so that, to
Contrast (difference)however, but, instead, whereas
Conditionif, when, unless

3. Sentence patterns that work

PatternExample
Sequence word, comma, then the stepFirst, I subtract 5 from both sides.
Step, then a purpose clauseI subtract 5 from both sides so that 3x is on its own.
Reason clause first, comma, then the stepBecause 3x means 3 × x, I divide both sides by 3.
Step, then a resultI divide both sides by 3, which gives x = 5.
Condition clause first, comma, then the resultIf I substitute x = 5 back in, I get 20, so my answer is correct.

Punctuation: put a comma after a sequence word at the start of a sentence (First, …) and after a clause that starts with because, if or when when it comes first. Two complete sentences cannot be joined with only a comma: use a full stop or a connective.

4. Rhian’s solution (correct, but no words)

4(x - 2) = 24 4x - 8 = 24 4x = 32 x = 8 Check: 4(8 - 2) = 4 × 6 = 24

5. Ioan’s explanation (correct, but choppy)

Ioan solved 5x − 7 = 2x + 11. He wrote:

I take 2x from both sides. I get 3x - 7 = 11. I add 7. I get 3x = 18. I divide by 3. x = 6.

6. Megan’s solution (has a mistake)

2x + 6 = 20 2x = 26 x = 13

7. A jumbled explanation

These 4 sentences explain how to solve (x + 4) ÷ 3 = 6, but they are in the wrong order.

CardSentence
AFinally, I subtract 4 from both sides, which gives x = 14.
BTo check, I substitute 14 back in: (14 + 4) ÷ 3 = 18 ÷ 3 = 6, which is correct.
CFirst, I multiply both sides by 3 because the whole of x + 4 is being divided by 3.
DThis means that x + 4 = 18.