Chromatography: Gwen’s write-up, her results and a punctuation guide
Gwen, her teacher, her write-up and her results are invented for practice. The practical is a real one that Year 7 pupils do in Science.
1. What the practical is about
The ink in a felt-tip pen is often a mixture of coloured dyes. Paper chromatography separates the dyes so you can see them.
Draw a base line in pencil near the bottom of the paper. Pencil does not dissolve in water, so the line stays put.
Put a small dot of ink from each pen on the base line.
Dip the bottom of the paper in water. Water is the solvent. It must be below the base line, or the ink washes off into the beaker.
The water moves up the paper and carries the dyes with it. Dyes that are more soluble in the water travel further up the paper.
The finished paper is called a chromatogram. A pure substance gives 1 spot. A mixture gives 2 or more spots. Spots from different pens that travel the same distance are probably the same dye.
2. Gwen’s write-up (with her punctuation mistakes)
Title: separating the dyes in felt-tip pens
Aim: to find out which pens ink is a mixture of dyes and which is a single pure dye
Equipment: i used this equipment chromatography paper a pencil a ruler 4 felt-tip pens a beaker water a glass rod and a paper clip
Method: first i drew a line 2 from the bottom of the paper this is called the base line. i drew it in pencil, pen ink would dissolve in the water. then i put a small dot of each pens ink on the line the dots were 2 cm apart. i poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep, the waters surface was below the base line. i hung the paper from the glass rod with a paper clip i left it for 10 minutes the water moved up the paper, it carried the dye’s with it.
Results: pen 1 gwens black pen made 3 spots purple blue and yellow. pen 2 green made 2 spots blue and yellow, pen 3 orange made 2 spots red and yellow. pen 4 yellow made only 1 spot. the yellow spot travelled 6.1 from the base line in all 4 pens inks the purple spot moved only 1.5cms. the water solvent travelled 8.0 cm.
Conclusion: my conclusion is that pen 4 is pure because it only made 1 spot, the other pens arent pure they are mixtures. i wonder if the yellow dye is the same in every pen? would i get the same results with a different solvent
Gwen’s teacher, Mr Prys, wrote: “Good science, Gwen, but the punctuation makes this hard to follow. Your conclusion is also too short. Use your results table to say which dyes are the most and least soluble, and which dyes the pens share.”
3. Gwen’s results (invented)
Pen
Colour of pen
Number of spots
Colours of the spots, bottom to top
Distance each spot travelled from the base line
1
black (Gwen’s pen)
3
purple, blue, yellow
1.5 cm, 3.8 cm, 6.1 cm
2
green
2
blue, yellow
3.8 cm, 6.1 cm
3
orange
2
red, yellow
2.4 cm, 6.1 cm
4
yellow
1
yellow
6.1 cm
The water (the solvent) travelled 8.0 cm up the paper from the base line.
Punctuation guide for science write-ups
Capital letters and full stops: every sentence starts with a capital letter and ends with a full stop. “I” is always a capital. I drew a base line. It was 2 cm from the bottom.
Comma splice: a comma cannot join 2 sentences. Use a full stop, or a joining word such as because, so or and. The water moved up the paper. It carried the dyes. or The water moved up the paper and carried the dyes.
Commas in a list: put a comma between the items and use and before the last one. I used a beaker, a ruler and a pencil.
Colon before a list: use a colon after a complete sentence that introduces a list. The black ink contained 3 dyes: purple, blue and yellow.
Apostrophe for one owner: add ’s. Gwen’s pen, the pen’s ink.
Apostrophe for more than one owner (when the word already ends in s): add ’ after the s. All 4 pens’ inks.
Apostrophe for missing letters:did not = didn’t, are not = aren’t. In a formal write-up, the full words are better.
No apostrophe for a plural: more than one dye is dyes, not dye’s.
Brackets: put extra information in brackets. The sentence must still make sense without it. Pen 2 (green) made 2 spots.
Numbers and units: leave a space between the number and the unit. Never add s or a full stop to a unit. 6.1 cm, not 6.1cms.
Question marks: only for a direct question. Would a different solvent change the results? A sentence that only reports a question ends with a full stop. I wonder if the dye is the same.