lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Design Technology · Year 8

5,127 tries: a case study in iterative design

Text A is a case study written for this lesson. The people, products, numbers and dates are real and widely published. Text B is invented.

Text A: the story of the bagless vacuum cleaner

Every product you own was designed, tested and improved, often many times. Designers call this iterative design: make a prototype, test it, find out what is wrong, change it, then test it again. One of the best known examples is the bagless vacuum cleaner designed by the British engineer and inventor James Dyson. His story shows that, in design, a failure is not the end of the story. It is information.

The problem

In the late 1970s, James Dyson was frustrated with the vacuum cleaner in his own home. Like almost every vacuum cleaner at the time, it collected dirt in a bag. Air was sucked through the bag, and the bag trapped the dust. The trouble was that the tiny holes in the bag soon clogged with fine dust. Once they were blocked, air could not flow through easily, so the cleaner lost suction long before the bag was full. Dyson saw this as a design fault, not just a nuisance. He wanted a vacuum cleaner that kept its suction all the time.

An idea from a sawmill

The answer came from an unexpected place. At a sawmill, Dyson saw an industrial cyclone: a large, cone-shaped machine that cleaned sawdust out of the air. Inside a cyclone, the air spins round very fast. The dust is flung outwards against the walls and drops down, out of the moving air, while the cleaner air carries on. There is no bag to clog. Dyson wondered whether the same idea could work in a machine small enough to push around a living room.

5,127 prototypes

Then the real work began. Over about 5 years, Dyson built and tested 5,127 prototypes. Each one was made, tested and studied to find out what went wrong. Then he changed something and tried again. Many of the changes were small: a slightly different shape, a different size, a new angle. Build. Test. Learn. Change. Repeat.

Think about what that number means. 5,127 prototypes means 5,126 that were not quite right. It works out at roughly 20 prototypes a week, every week, for about 5 years. It would have been easy to give up after prototype 50, or prototype 500. Yet each failure taught him something that made the next prototype a little better, and slowly the problems were solved one by one.

From Japan to the UK

Even with a working design, success did not come quickly. Dyson could not persuade the big British vacuum cleaner makers to take on his idea. At the time, those companies also sold the replacement bags that their vacuum cleaners needed. Instead, his design was first sold in Japan, in the 1980s, as the G-Force. Money from the Japanese deal helped him set up his own company in Britain.

In 1993, the DC01 was launched in the UK. It was the first vacuum cleaner sold under the Dyson name. It used cyclones instead of a bag, and it had a see-through bin, so people could watch the dust it collected. Later models carried on the same process of testing and improving.

What designers can learn

This story is famous because it makes iterative design easy to see. Dyson did not have one brilliant idea and then stop. He had one good idea, and then he improved it thousands of times. Designers today still work in this way, whether they are developing a chair, a phone or a bicycle helmet. They sketch, model, test and evaluate, and every round of testing tells them what to change next.

The lesson for any designer, including you in your Design Technology lessons, is simple. A prototype that fails has still done its job if it teaches you something. The only real failure is to stop learning.

Glossary

Text B: a pupil’s design blog

This blog post is invented for this lesson. Osian, his teacher and his school project are not real.

Osian’s DT Diary · Year 8, Llandeilo · Post 6: My phone stand, 4 versions and counting!

So, our Design Technology project this term is a phone stand, and I’ll be honest: version 1 was a disaster. I made it out of card in about 10 minutes, put my phone on it and… it fell flat on its face. Literally.

Version 2 had a wider base, so it stopped tipping over. Progress! But my phone slid straight off the front because the slope was too steep. Mrs Pritchard said that’s exactly what testing is for, which was annoying, because she was right.

For version 3, I added a little lip at the front to stop the phone sliding. It worked! Then I tried to charge my phone and realised the lip blocked the cable. Back to the drawing board (well, the cardboard).

Version 4 has a gap cut in the lip for the cable, and I tested it with 3 different phones from my class. All 3 stayed put. Next week I’m making it in plywood.

Top tip if you’re doing this project: don’t panic when something goes wrong. Every version that failed showed me exactly what to fix next. Has your prototype ever totally flopped? Tell me in the comments!