lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Science · Year 9

Two articles about Morlyn Bae Gwenith, a tidal lagoon

The lagoon, the bay, the organisations, the people and every figure on this sheet are invented for practice. The science of how a tidal lagoon works is real.

Text A: How a tidal lagoon makes electricity

From a leaflet by Canolfan Wyddoniaeth Glannau, a science centre

Twice a day, the sea rises and falls. These tides are caused mainly by the pull of the Moon’s gravity on the oceans, with a smaller pull from the Sun. Because the movements of the Moon and the Sun are known, tide times and heights can be predicted many years ahead. This makes the tide a predictable source of energy, unlike the wind.

A tidal lagoon is a wall built out into the sea to enclose part of a bay. As the tide rises outside, the water level outside the wall becomes higher than the level inside. The sluice gates stay closed until the difference in height is large enough. Then water is let in through tunnels in the wall. Inside each tunnel it turns a turbine, which drives a generator. When the tide falls, the process is reversed and water flows out through the same turbines. The turbines are bidirectional, so they generate electricity on both the incoming and the outgoing tide.

No fuel is burned while a lagoon generates electricity, so it does not release carbon dioxide. However, building the wall uses large amounts of rock and concrete. The wall also changes the intertidal zone inside the lagoon, the area of mud and sand that is covered at high tide and uncovered at low tide. This zone is a feeding ground for wading birds. Fine sediment may settle in the calmer water behind the wall, and fish may be injured if they pass through the turbines.

A lagoon produces most power when the difference in water height is greatest, so its output rises and falls during the day and there are short times when it produces none.

Text B: “Power from the bay, but at what cost?”

From Y Glannau, a weekly local newspaper

Plans for a £1.1 billion tidal lagoon in Bae Gwenith have divided the town. The developer, Ynni Môr Gwenith, wants to build a 7 km wall with 14 turbines. It says the lagoon could generate up to 210 megawatts, enough electricity for about 120,000 homes, and would work for 120 years.

“This is the most exciting thing to happen to our coast in a century,” said project director Rhian Owen. “The tide comes in every single day. It will never let us down, and it will bring 400 jobs while we build it.”

Not everyone agrees. Fisherman Dafydd Morgan, whose family has fished the bay for four generations, said: “They talk about 400 jobs, but most of those last only for the 4 years of building. What about the fish? Nobody can tell me how many will be killed in those turbines.”

Local birdwatcher Carys Jenkins is also worried. “Up to 3,000 wading birds feed on these mud flats every winter. Once the wall is built, the mud inside will be covered for longer. Where will they go?”

The tidal range in the bay reaches 9 metres, one of the largest in the area. Supporters say this makes it an ideal site. Critics point out that the cost per unit of electricity would be higher than from wind farms at sea. A decision is expected next spring.

Reminder: reading strategies