lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Science · Year 7
Purifying rock salt: Nia’s notes and a model method
Nia and her notes are invented for practice. The practical is a real one that Year 7 pupils do in Science.
1. What the practical is about
Rock salt is dug out of the ground. It is a mixture of salt and sand. Salt dissolves in water, but sand does not. So you can separate them:
- Dissolving: stir the rock salt in warm water. The salt dissolves to make a salt solution. The sand does not.
- Filtering: pour the mixture through filter paper. The sand stays in the paper. This is the residue. The salt solution runs through. This is the filtrate.
- Evaporating: heat the filtrate gently so some of the water evaporates, then leave it somewhere warm. Salt crystals are left behind.
2. The equipment Nia used
Pestle and mortar · spatula · 100 cm3 beaker · measuring cylinder · glass stirring rod · filter paper · filter funnel · conical flask · evaporating basin · Bunsen burner, tripod and gauze · heatproof mat · eye protection · rock salt · warm water
3. Nia’s notes
First we got the rock salt and we smashed it up. Then we put it in the water and we stirred it for a bit. Before that we put the water in the beaker, about 50 of it. Then we did the filter thing and the sand stayed in the paper. The water that came through went in the dish. We heated it up till it started spitting which was really cool!! We left it on the side and next lesson there were loads of salt crystals.
Nia’s teacher wrote: “Great practical, Nia. But this is a story of what you did, not a method. Could someone who missed the lesson follow it? Rewrite it as a method.”
4. A model method from a different practical
Which soil holds the most water?
Aim: To find out which of 3 soils holds the most water.
Equipment:
- 3 filter funnels and 3 filter papers
- 3 measuring cylinders (100 cm3)
- sand, clay soil and compost
- a spatula and a beaker of water
- a stopwatch
Method:
- Put a filter paper in each funnel and stand each funnel in a measuring cylinder.
- Add 5 spatulas of sand to the first funnel, 5 spatulas of clay soil to the second and 5 spatulas of compost to the third.
- Pour 50 cm3 of water onto each soil at the same time.
- Start the stopwatch.
- After 5 minutes, read the volume of water in each measuring cylinder.
- Record the results in a table.
Safety: Wash your hands after touching soil. Wipe up spilt water straight away so nobody slips.
Word bank: command verbs for a method
Add · Crush · Fold · Heat · Leave · Measure · Place · Pour · Put · Record · Stir · Stop · Wait
What makes a good method
- A title and an aim that says what you are trying to find out or make.
- An equipment list, written as a list, with sizes where they matter.
- Numbered steps in the order you do them, one action in each step.
- Each step starts with a command verb (an instruction), not “we” or “I”.
- Quantities with units, such as 50 cm3 or 5 minutes, so someone else could repeat it exactly.
- Precise scientific names for equipment, such as evaporating basin, not dish.
- A safety point that says what the danger is and what to do about it.