lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Design Technology · Year 9

Nythfa bird box: joining methods fact file

The Nythfa bird box, its specification, the making times and the pupil Dylan are invented for this lesson. The facts about each joint are general Design and Technology knowledge.

1. The product

Nythfa means a nesting place. The Nythfa bird box is made from 15 mm pine, a softwood, and has a 25 mm entrance hole, a size often used for blue tits. It must:

The box has 4 corners to join. The fact cards below compare 4 ways of joining them. The times are for one corner, made by hand by a Year 9 pupil.

2. Fact cards

A. Butt joint with glue and pins

How it is made: two pieces with square-cut ends meet. They are glued with wood glue and held with panel pins (small thin nails) hammered through.

Strengths: the quickest and simplest joint; easy to cut accurately; needs few tools.

Weaknesses: the weakest of the four. The glue is on end grain, which soaks up glue and grips poorly, so the joint relies on the pins. Steel pins rust outdoors unless they are galvanised (coated with zinc).

Tools: try square, tenon saw, bench hook, hammer. Time: about 10 minutes.

B. Finger joint (also called a comb joint)

How it is made: square “fingers” are cut into the ends of both pieces, so they lock together like two combs, then glued.

Strengths: very strong, because the fingers give a large gluing area; looks attractive; resists pulling apart in several directions.

Weaknesses: slow; needs very accurate marking out; any mistake leaves visible gaps. Hard to cut well with hand tools.

Tools: marking gauge, try square, tenon saw, coping saw, chisel, mallet. Time: about 60 minutes.

C. Dowel joint

How it is made: matching holes are drilled into both pieces. Short round wooden pegs called dowels are glued into the holes, joining the pieces.

Strengths: stronger than a butt joint, because the dowels add gluing area and stop the pieces sliding; hidden from view, so it looks neat; no metal to rust.

Weaknesses: the holes must line up exactly, or the joint will not close; drilling too near an edge can split the wood.

Tools: drill, dowel jig, mallet. Time: about 25 minutes.

D. Knock-down fittings

How it is made: ready-made metal or plastic fittings, such as corner blocks with screws, join the pieces without glue.

Strengths: can be taken apart and put back together, for example to clean the box; quick to fit; no glue to dry.

Weaknesses: can work loose over time; the fittings show; each one costs money; steel fittings rust outdoors unless coated or stainless.

Tools: drill, screwdriver. Time: about 15 minutes.

For any glued joint on an outdoor product, use a waterproof (exterior) wood glue.

3. Dylan’s answer

Question: Compare a butt joint and a finger joint for the Nythfa bird box.

Dylan, Year 9, wrote: “Butt joint. It is quick. It is easy. It is weak. Finger joint. It is strong. It takes a long time. It looks good. I would use a finger joint.”

His teacher wrote: “Correct ideas, but this is a list. Link your points with connectives, give evidence from the fact file and say why it matters for a bird box.”