lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Geography · Year 9
The quarry, the village, the people and every figure on this sheet are invented for practice. The kinds of issues are the ones that real quarry decisions in Wales involve.
| Option | What it means |
|---|---|
| A | Approve the extension as the owners propose it. |
| B | Approve it with extra conditions that the group agrees, for example on lorry times, the woodland or dust. |
| C | Refuse the extension. The quarry closes in about 3 years. |
Cut along the lines or fold the sheet so each person sees only their own card until the meeting starts.
| Role | Your view and what you care about |
|---|---|
| 1. Chair of the community council meeting (every group) | You do not take sides. You open the meeting, give each person 1 minute to speak, keep people to time, make sure everyone is heard, sum up and lead the group to a decision. If the group cannot agree, you hold a vote. You also fill in the decision form. |
| 2. Quarry manager, Mererid Hughes (every group) | You want Option A. The quarry supports 42 families and many local suppliers. Wales needs stone for roads and houses, and bringing it from further away means more lorry miles. You think the community fund and replanting are a fair offer. You would accept some conditions if they do not make the quarry too expensive to run. |
| 3. Resident, Alun Parry, a parent at the primary school (every group) | You want Option C, or very strict conditions. 110 lorries a day past the school worries you. Dust settles on cars and washing, and the blasting shakes windows. You are not against jobs, but you think the village pays the price for them. |
| 4. Wildlife officer, Dr Sara Bowen (every group) | You are worried about losing 5 hectares of old woodland and the dormice that live there. Replanting in 15 years is not the same as old woodland now. You might accept Option B if the woodland is protected or the extension is made smaller. |
| 5. Apprentice, Jac Morris, aged 19 (groups of 5 or 6) | You want Option A. You started at the quarry last year. There are few other jobs in the valley for young people, and your friends have moved away to find work. You want to stay in Llanwenfor. |
| 6. Café owner, Nerys Lloyd (groups of 6) | You are undecided. Quarry workers and lorry drivers buy lunch in your café every day. But walkers also come for the quiet hills and the woods, and they complain about the lorries. You want the option that is best for the whole village in the long term. |