lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Maths · Year 8

Phone contracts for Elin and Osian

The people, the phone companies and the deals on this sheet are invented. Real phone deals change often, so do not use these prices outside this lesson.

1. Elin’s problem

Elin is 16 and lives in Pontypridd. She wants a new phone on a 24-month deal. She streams music on the bus to college and uses about 25 GB of data a month. She has £150 saved from her weekend job, and she does not want to spend more than that at the start. Her favourite colour is green, and she would like a phone with a good camera.

She asks you: “Which deal should I choose? Show me all your working and explain each step, because I want to understand it.”

2. The three deals

DealCompanyPay at the startPay each monthData each month
ADraig Mobile£0£32 for 24 months. First 3 months half price.30 GB
BCwmwl£99£26 for 24 months100 GB
CSgwrs£459 to buy the phone outright£10 for a SIM for 24 months20 GB

All three deals include the same phone, 5G and unlimited calls and texts.

3. Two answers from last year’s Year 8

Two pupils answered Elin’s question. Both got some of the maths right. Read them carefully.

Answer X, by Dylan

16 x 3 = 48 21 x 32 = 672 720 99 + 624 = 723 459 + 240 = 699 C

Answer Y, by Nia

First I found the total cost of Deal A. For the first 3 months it is half price, so 3 x £16 = £48. Then there are 21 months left at £32, so 21 x £32 = £672. So Deal A costs £48 + £672 = £720 altogether. Deal B costs 99 + 24 x 26 = £723. Deal C 459 + 240 = 699 so Deal C is the cheapest.

4. What a well-organised answer does

In GCSE Mathematics and Numeracy examinations, some marks are for organising and communicating your answer, not just for the numbers. A well-organised answer:

  1. says what is being worked out before each calculation;
  2. shows every calculation with the numbers and the units (£, GB, months);
  3. puts the steps in a sensible order and joins them with linking words;
  4. ends with a conclusion that answers the question and gives a reason using the numbers;
  5. checks the answer against everything the question says, not only the cost.

5. Word bank

To start a stepTo link stepsTo conclude
First I found…
Next I worked out…
To compare the deals, I…
so…
then…
this means that…
because…
however…
Therefore…
Overall…
This shows that…
I would recommend… because…

6. Osian’s problem

Osian is Elin’s cousin. He uses about 5 GB of data a month and has no savings, so he cannot pay anything at the start.

DealPay at the startPay each monthData each month
D£0£18 a month for the first 12 months, then the price rises to £19.50 a month for the last 12 months10 GB
E£0£19 a month, fixed for all 24 months8 GB