dcf.cymru stimulus sheet · Geography · Year 11

Pont-rhaf flood options briefing

Pont-rhaf and the Afon Rhaf are invented, and so are all the figures on this sheet. The method is real, though simplified. Flood schemes in Wales are judged by comparing the damage a scheme would prevent with what it costs, and then weighing up things money cannot measure.

1 — The problem

Pont-rhaf is a small town where the Afon Rhaf leaves the hills. Two hundred homes lie in three flood zones. The council has been offered £2.0 million to spend up front on flood protection and must choose what to spend it on.

A “1-in-10-year flood” is a flood so big that it has a 10% chance (0.1) of happening in any one year. It does not mean one flood every ten years. Two can happen in two years running. A 1-in-50-year flood has a 2% chance each year (0.02), and a 1-in-200-year flood has a 0.5% chance (0.005). A bigger flood floods everything a smaller one does, and more.

2 — The map

Upper Cwm Rhaf 200 ha of hill grazing: where Option B would go Pont-rhaf Zone 3: 100 homes Zone 2: 60 homes Zone 1: 40 homes Zone 3 Zone 2 Zone 1 Afon Rhaf flows east → Afon Rhaf Option A flood wall (both banks) Option B tree planting and leaky dams Sketch map, not to scale. North is at the top.

3 — The flood zones today

Zone Homes Floods in a flood of this size or bigger Annual chance Average damage to one flooded home
1401-in-10-year0.1£30,000
2601-in-50-year0.02£30,000
31001-in-200-year0.005£30,000

The damage figure covers repairs, lost belongings and the cost of living somewhere else while the house dries out. It cannot count the fear, the lost photographs or the months of disruption.

4 — The options

Option What it does to the model Up-front cost Yearly upkeep Notes
A — Flood wall along both banks through the town Holds back every flood up to 1-in-100-year. A bigger flood goes over the top and floods Zones 1 and 2 anyway. New annual chances: Zone 1: 0.01 · Zone 2: 0.01 · Zone 3: 0.005 (unchanged). £4,000,000 £25,000 Two years to design and build. Cuts the town off from its river, and the riverbank habitat is lost.
B — Natural flood management in Upper Cwm Rhaf Leaky wooden dams, ponds and tree planting slow the water down, so the river peaks lower. New annual chances: Zone 1: 0.05 · Zone 2: 0.0125 · Zone 3: 0.004. £1,200,000 £15,000 The leaky dams work within a year or two, but the trees take 10–15 years to have their full effect. New woodland and wetland for wildlife. Farmers must agree to it.
C — Property flood resilience for the 40 homes in Zone 1 Flood doors, non-return valves, raised sockets and tiled floors. Floods happen just as often, but damage to a flooded Zone 1 home falls to £9,000. Zones 2 and 3 are unchanged. £480,000 (40 × £12,000) £8,000 Fitted within six months. Families must put the barriers up themselves when a flood warning comes. Water still gets into the street.
B+C — both together Option B's annual chances, and Option C's £9,000 damage for Zone 1 homes. £1,680,000 £23,000 Protection starts in Zone 1 within six months and grows as the trees mature.

Every option is judged over 50 years. Real appraisals also “discount” future money, so that a pound saved in 40 years' time counts for less than a pound today. This model leaves that out.

5 — Scoring things that are not money

Each option is scored from 1 (worst) to 5 (best) on five criteria. You work out the first two from your own model. The other three have been scored by the council's project team:

Criterion How to score it
Value for moneyFrom the benefit–cost ratio (BCR). Below 1.0 scores 1 · 1.0 to 1.49 scores 2 · 1.5 to 2.49 scores 3 · 2.5 to 3.99 scores 4 · 4.0 or more scores 5
Homes still flooded in a 1-in-50-year floodNone scores 5 · 1 to 50 homes scores 3 · more than 50 homes scores 1
Option Environment and wildlife How soon it works Community support
A — wall132 (residents want protection but not a wall hiding the river)
B — natural514
C — resilience353 (some owners do not want works in their homes)
B+C544

6 — Three people, three sets of priorities

Each person shares out 10 points of weight across the five criteria. A weighted total is each score multiplied by its weight, all added up. The highest possible total is 50.

Stakeholder Value for money Homes still flooded Environment How soon Community
Council finance officer52111
Pont-rhaf residents' flood group15121
River ecologist22411

7 — A what-if scenario (Step 5 only)

Suppose that by the 2070s wetter winters make every flood twice as likely, so every annual chance in the model doubles. For example, Zone 1 today goes from 0.1 to 0.2. This is a scenario for testing the model, not an official forecast for any real river.