lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · English · Year 10
Two original speeches written for practice. The town of Pontarddu, Dyffryn Du County Borough Council, Friends of Pontarddu Library, both speakers and all the figures are invented. They are not about any real library or council.
Print it single-sided: 2 pages, one set between two pupils. Page 1 is Pupil A’s speech. Page 2 is Pupil B’s speech. Keep your speech face down until it is your turn to read. The listener must not see the speech they are listening to until Step 3 of the worksheet.
The council wants to move Pontarddu Library out of its old building in the town centre and into the leisure centre, with self-service machines. Both speeches were given at a public meeting in Pontarddu Community Hall on a Thursday at 19:00. Each speech takes about 2 minutes to read aloud.
Saying the names: Pontarddu: say “pont-ARTH-ee” (the “dd” sounds like “th” in “this”) · Stryd y Farchnad (Market Street): say “streed uh VARKH-nad” (the “ch” is the throaty sound in “loch”) · Dyffryn Du: say “DUFF-rin DEE” · Meirion: say “MAY-ree-on”.
Speaker: Councillor Meirion Howells, Cabinet Member for Communities and Leisure, Dyffryn Du County Borough Council.
How to read: read it like a confident speaker at a public meeting: clear, steady, not too fast. Pause at every full stop and a little longer between paragraphs. Read the whole speech twice: the first time your partner just listens, the second time your partner makes notes.
Good evening, and thank you for coming. I want to start by saying something clearly, because there have been a lot of rumours. We are not closing Pontarddu Library. We are moving it, and we are making it better.
Let us be honest about where we are. The library building on Stryd y Farchnad opened in 1910. It is a beautiful old building, but it is crumbling. The roof leaks, the heating fails every winter, and our surveyors say it needs £640,000 of repairs over the next 10 years. That is money swallowed by a leaking roof, instead of spent on books and people.
And fewer people are coming through the door. In 2015 the library had 98,000 visits. Last year it had 61,000. That is a fall of more than a third. Most people now borrow e-books on their phones. The world has changed, and our library must change with it.
So here is our plan. We will move the library into Pontarddu Leisure Centre: a modern, vibrant hub for the whole community, with free parking for 200 cars. Thanks to new self-service technology, the library will be open from 07:00 to 22:00, 7 days a week. That is 105 hours a week, nearly 3 times the 38 hours it opens now. Parents can pick up a book after a swimming lesson. Workers can call in on the way home.
Running the library in its new home will cost £120,000 a year, instead of £210,000. That saves £90,000 every single year: money that will protect other vital services.
We asked you what you wanted. In our online survey, 7 out of 10 people said they would use a library that was open in the evenings. We listened. These are tough choices, but this is a library fit for the 21st century. Thank you.
Speaker: Bethan Rowlands, chair of Friends of Pontarddu Library, a volunteer campaign group.
How to read: read it like a passionate speaker at a public meeting: clear and strong, with feeling. Pause at every full stop, and pause before each question as if you are waiting for an answer. Read the whole speech twice: the first time your partner just listens, the second time your partner makes notes.
Friends, neighbours, thank you. My name is Bethan Rowlands, and I have used Pontarddu Library since I was 5 years old.
The council says it is not closing our library. So why does this feel like a funeral? Because this plan rips the heart out of our town. The library sits on Stryd y Farchnad, in the middle of everything: next to the bus stop, the chemist and the primary school. The leisure centre is 2 miles away, on the edge of town. There is 1 bus an hour, and no bus at all on Sundays. How is a pensioner without a car meant to get there? How is a child meant to get there after school? 1 in 4 of our library users is over 65. Did anyone ask them?
We did. Our petition has 3,200 signatures, collected on paper, on doorsteps and in the library itself. Not in an online survey that only people with the internet could fill in.
And look at what they are offering. Our library would be squeezed into a corner of a sports hall. Today it holds 22,000 books. The new space holds 9,000. More than half our books will simply disappear. The library will be staffed for just 20 hours a week, instead of 38. The rest of the time, you get a machine. A machine cannot help a nervous 8 year old choose her first chapter book. A machine cannot help a man fill in a job application. Our 12 public computers were used 9,000 times last year, for job searches, benefit claims and homework.
People say nobody uses libraries any more. Wrong. Visits have gone up by 13% in the last 2 years, from 54,000 to 61,000. Pontarddu Library is not dying. It is fighting back. So please, stand with us, and do not let them take it from us.