lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Food and Nutrition · Year 11

How much baking powder makes the best scone? The results

Rhys, his investigation and every result on this sheet are invented practice data. The food science is real.

1. The investigation

Question: How does the amount of baking powder affect the rise and the flavour of scones?

Rhys’s hypothesis: “The more baking powder I add, the higher and better the scones will be.”

Method: Rhys made 4 batches of plain scones with 225 g plain flour, 50 g butter and 150 ml milk. The only thing he changed was the baking powder: 0 g, 6 g, 12 g and 18 g. He rolled every batch to 2 cm thick, cut 3 scones with the same 5 cm cutter and baked them at 220 °C for 12 minutes. When they were cool, he measured the height of each scone with a ruler. Then 6 tasters scored each batch from 1 (low) to 5 (high).

2. Height results

Baking powderScone 1 (mm)Scone 2 (mm)Scone 3 (mm)Mean height (mm)
0 g17181918
6 g28302929
12 g37393838
18 g40434041

3. Taste panel results (mean of 6 tasters, out of 5)

Baking powderLight, open textureSoapy or bitter aftertasteOverall liking
0 g1.51.02.0
6 g3.21.33.5
12 g4.31.84.3
18 g4.04.22.2

What the tasters said:

4. The food science

5. Rhys’s rough notes

0 g scones rose 18 mm. 12 g scones rose 38 mm. 18 g scones tallest. Tasters did not like them. Baking powder gives off CO2. Scones rise. 12 g best texture. 12 g highest overall score. Height went up 11 mm from 0 g to 6 g. Only 3 mm from 12 g to 18 g. 18 g tasted soapy. Too much alkali left. Hypothesis partly right?