lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · RE · Year 11

“Religious believers should always forgive.” A views pack

The teachings in Part 1 are real. The four people quoted in Part 2 are invented for practice.

Part 1: teachings

BeliefTeaching
Christianity
  • In the Lord’s Prayer, Christians ask God to “forgive us our sins, as we forgive those who sin against us”.
  • Peter asked Jesus if he should forgive someone up to seven times. Jesus replied, “not seven times, but seventy-seven times” (Matthew 18:21 to 22), meaning without limit.
  • On the cross Jesus prayed, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing” (Luke 23:34).
  • Many Christians teach that forgiving someone does not mean there should be no justice or punishment.
Islam
  • One of the names of Allah is Al-Ghafur, the Forgiving.
  • The Qur’an teaches that the payment for a harm can be a harm like it, “but whoever pardons and makes reconciliation, his reward is due from Allah” (Surah 42:40). Justice is allowed, but forgiveness is praised.
  • Surah 24:22 asks believers to pardon and overlook: “Would you not like that Allah should forgive you?”
Judaism
  • On Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, Jews ask God to forgive their sins.
  • Jewish tradition teaches that God forgives sins against God, but for a wrong done to another person, the wrongdoer must first go to that person, make amends and ask for their forgiveness. This process of turning back is called teshuvah.
  • A person who is sincerely asked for forgiveness is expected not to refuse it for ever.
Humanism
  • Humanists do not believe in a god who forgives. They decide what is right by thinking about the effects of actions on people.
  • Many humanists think forgiveness can be good: it can help victims move on and repair relationships.
  • But humanists do not see forgiveness as a duty. It may depend on whether the wrongdoer is sorry, whether the harm is still going on, and what is best for the victim’s well-being.

Part 2: four voices (invented)

Siân, a Christian youth leader: “Forgiving is not saying that what happened was fine. It is choosing not to carry hatred. Jesus forgave the people killing him, so there is nothing I cannot at least try to forgive.”

Tariq, a Muslim teacher: “Islam gives a victim the right to justice. Forgiveness is better and brings a reward from Allah, but it is a choice, not a command in every case.”

Rachel, a Jewish nurse: “Forgiveness is not automatic. The person who hurt you has to take responsibility first. If they are truly sorry, then you should forgive.”

Owen, a humanist counsellor: “I have met people who felt pressured to forgive before they were ready, and it hurt them more. Forgiveness can be healing, but it should never be forced, and it should not put anyone at risk.”

What “evaluate” means

Consider arguments for and against the statement, judge how strong each one is, and reach a justified conclusion. You must refer to religious and non-religious beliefs. Pay attention to every word in the statement, especially “always”.