lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Art · Year 11

Ysgol Tanygraig critique: 3 portfolio cards

Ysgol Tanygraig, Macsen, Efa, Ioan and their portfolios are invented for this lesson. Practice only, not NEA work: nobody in the room discusses their own portfolio.

How to use the cards

When you are the Artist, you speak as the pupil on the card, in the first person: “I chose…”, “My intention was…”. Defend your choices with reasons. If you are asked something the card does not cover, invent an answer that fits the card and stay in role. The Questioner and Recorder may read the card too.

Card 1 (Round 1): Macsen, “Working Hands”

Intention: to show the hands of people in my family who do physical work, and what their jobs leave on them. My mam is a nurse and my taid was a farmer for 50 years.

The problem I hit: the painting looks flat next to the drawings. When I blended the skin tones they went muddy. I cannot decide whether to start again or keep going.

If asked: I love the biro drawings most. Taid nearly refused to be cast. I chose acrylic because it dries fast, but that makes blending hard. I have 3 weeks left.

Card 2 (Round 2): Efa, “Layers of the High Street”

Intention: to show how my town’s high street has changed over 100 years, by layering the old and the new so you can see both at once.

The problem I hit: at our mock display, visitors loved the textile piece but did not understand it. From 2 m away it is too pale to read, and nobody saw it was a map.

If asked: the postcards came from my nain’s drawer. I chose white because it feels like memory fading. I am worried that adding colour would ruin the delicate look.

Card 3 (Round 3): Ioan, “Noise”

Intention: to turn the sounds of my 40-minute bus journey to school into marks and patterns: the engine, the doors, people talking, the rain.

The problem I hit: my teacher said the patterns look like wallpaper, not noise. I am also running out of time for the lino print.

If asked: the loudest sound was the doors hissing. My best marks came from the rain recording. I prefer the energy of the ink drawings to the neat digital patterns, but the patterns took longest.