lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · RE · Year 7

Why be kind? Three talks to read aloud

Talks 1 and 2 retell a Christian parable and a traditional Sikh story. The speaker in Talk 3, Dr Elin Rowlands, is invented for practice; her talk sums up humanist ideas.

For the cover teacher

Read each talk aloud at a steady pace, as if giving a short assembly. Each takes about 2 minutes. Read each talk twice: pupils listen the first time and make notes the second time. Pause for 1 minute after each second reading. Do not hand this sheet out until Step 6, when pairs use it to check their notes.

Talk 1: the Good Samaritan (Christianity)

This is a story that Jesus told. You can find it in the Bible, in the Gospel of Luke, chapter 10.

An expert in the Jewish law asked Jesus what he must do to have eternal life. Jesus asked him what the law said. The man answered: love God with all your heart, and love your neighbour as yourself. Then the man asked, “But who is my neighbour?”

Jesus answered with a story. A man was travelling on the lonely road from Jerusalem down to Jericho. Robbers attacked him, took his clothes, beat him and left him half dead. A priest came along the road. He saw the man, and passed by on the other side. Then a Levite, who also worked in the Temple, came along. He too passed by on the other side.

Then a Samaritan came along. At that time, Jews and Samaritans were enemies. But when the Samaritan saw the man, he felt sorry for him. He cleaned and bandaged his wounds with oil and wine, put him on his own donkey and took him to an inn. The next day he gave the innkeeper two silver coins and said, “Look after him, and when I come back I will pay you for anything extra you spend.”

Jesus asked: which of the three was a neighbour to the man who was attacked? The expert answered, “The one who showed him mercy.” Jesus said, “Go and do the same.”

For Christians, the message is that your neighbour is anyone who needs help, even a stranger or an enemy.

Talk 2: Bhai Kanhaiya (Sikhism)

This is a story that Sikhs have told for more than 300 years. It comes from the time of Guru Gobind Singh, the tenth Sikh Guru, in the early 1700s, when the Sikhs were fighting battles against the armies of the Mughal emperor.

After one battle, the ground was covered with wounded soldiers. They were desperate for water. A Sikh called Bhai Kanhaiya walked among them with a water bag. He gave water to every wounded man he found: Sikh soldiers, and enemy soldiers too.

Some Sikh soldiers were furious. They complained to Guru Gobind Singh: “This man is helping our enemies get well so that they can fight us again!”

The Guru sent for Bhai Kanhaiya and asked him if this was true. Bhai Kanhaiya answered that it was. He said that when he looked at the wounded men, he did not see friends or enemies. He saw the same light of God in every face.

The Guru was pleased. He praised Bhai Kanhaiya and gave him ointment and bandages, so that he could treat the wounds of every soldier as well as giving them water.

Sikhs call this kind of help seva: selfless service, done without wanting a reward. The story teaches that God is in everyone, so everyone deserves help.

Talk 3: a humanist view (invented speaker)

Bore da. My name is Dr Elin Rowlands and I am a humanist. Humanists do not believe in a god. We think this life is the only one we have, so we should try to make it as good as possible, for ourselves and for other people.

So why should I be kind, if there is no god watching and no reward after death? I have two reasons.

The first is empathy. I can imagine how another person feels. If I know how it feels to be lonely, scared or hurt, I can work out what might help someone else.

The second is reason. When I think it through, I can see that people do better when they look after each other. A town where people help strangers is a better place for everyone to live, including me.

Many humanists use the Golden Rule: treat other people as you would want to be treated. It is found in many religions, but you do not need to be religious to see that it makes sense.

Last winter I helped at a community café in my town, where anyone can get a hot meal and a chat. I did not do it to get to heaven. I did it because the people there matter, and because I could.

Kindness, for humanists, comes from understanding each other, not from being told.