lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · Music · Year 8
Please share this sheet between two and do not write on it. Use the concert programme, the 12 raw listening notes and the musical vocabulary glossary below to plan and write your comparative review.
At the Tresaith Summer Music Evening in Ceredigion, the concert ended with two contrasting live arrangements of the famous traditional Welsh melody Ar Hyd y Nos (All Through the Night). A Year 8 reviewer for the school’s online magazine, Cerdd Cymru, jotted down 12 raw observations on a tablet during the concert.
| Feature | Performance A: Solo Acoustic Arrangement | Performance B: Colliery Brass Band Arrangement |
|---|---|---|
| Performer(s) | Catrin Llwyd (solo acoustic Welsh triple harp, telyn deires) | Band Pres Cwmaman (28-piece traditional Welsh brass band with percussion) |
| Stage setting | Single wooden stool at the front of the stage, lit by a single warm spotlight; no microphone amplification | Full semicircular band formation across the stage with a conductor on the podium |
These 12 observations were typed quickly in the order the reviewer noticed them, mixing up tempo, dynamics, instrumentation and mood. In Step 1 on your worksheet, you will sort Notes 1 to 12 into four logical categories.
| Note | Performance | Raw listening observation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Performance A (Harp) | Played on a traditional wooden triple harp with three rows of strings; the plucked strings had a warm, delicate, ringing sound (resonant timbre). |
| 2 | Performance A (Harp) | Moved at a gentle walking speed (andante, around 68 BPM), slowing down Expressively at the end of each verse (rubato). |
| 3 | Performance B (Brass) | Verse 1 began moderately quietly (mezzo-piano) in the lower horns so the audience leaned in to listen. |
| 4 | Performance B (Brass) | A solo flugelhorn played the opening verse melody with a mellow, velvety brass tone before the cornets, euphoniums and deep Bb tubas joined in. |
| 5 | Performance A (Harp) | Stayed quiet (piano) for the whole piece, dropping to very quiet (pianissimo) on the high harmonics at the end. |
| 6 | Performance A (Harp) | The left hand played flowing broken chords (arpeggios) underneath a single smooth (legato) melody line, creating a peaceful, lullaby-like mood. |
| 7 | Performance B (Brass) | Taken at a slower, stately speed (adagio, around 60 BPM) with a strict, steady pulse held firmly by the conductor’s baton. |
| 8 | Performance A (Harp) | In Verse 2, Catrin plucked high bell-like notes near the middle of the strings (harmonics) that shimmered in the quiet hall. |
| 9 | Performance B (Brass) | In the final verse, a deep timpani roll underpinned the full 28-piece brass ensemble, filling the hall with a rich, sonorous wall of sound. |
| 10 | Performance A (Harp) | Only rose slightly in volume during the middle bridge before sinking back to a whisper, never forcing the sound. |
| 11 | Performance B (Brass) | All 28 players moved together in thick 4-part block chords (homophonic texture), creating a proud, uplifting and majestic atmosphere. |
| 12 | Performance B (Brass) | Built through a long, powerful crescendo across Verse 2 to reach a thrilling fortissimo climax on the final sustained chord. |
Precise musical terms (use these instead of vague words like “nice”, “loud”, “fast” or “thick”):
Comparative connectives for joining ideas:
whereas · in contrast · while · on the other hand · unlike · similarly · both arrangements