Cover lesson · Science · Year 9 · Advanced

Analysing an article on antibiotic resistance

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Antibiotic resistance: a feature article and a social media post”, one per pupil if possible so pupils can highlight it (otherwise one between two). No practical work and no computers. Pupils need a pen and 2 highlighters of different colours. If there are no highlighters, pupils underline and circle instead.

Run: 8 min pupils read both texts · 6 min Step 2, finding and inferring · 8 min Step 3, fact, opinion or misleading claim · 8 min Step 4, how the writer persuades · 6 min Step 5, comparing the texts · 14 min Step 6, extended answer, alone and in silence · 5 min Step 7, the science in 5 sentences · 3 min success criteria. Total 58 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice in reading: finding information, inferring, separating fact from opinion, analysing how a writer persuades and judging how reliable a text is. Step 6 is the main assessed piece of writing; Step 7 checks the science. It builds towards reading and evaluating scientific information in GCSE The Sciences (Double Award). Model answers, all answers and a mark guide are on the worked example.

What you are doing

Antibiotics are some of the most important medicines ever discovered, but they are losing their power. You will read a newspaper feature about antibiotic resistance and a social media post that gives very different advice. You will work out what each text says, how the article persuades its readers, and which text you can trust.

Step 1: read the texts

Read Text A, the feature article, all the way through. Then read Text B and its 2 replies. Use the key words box at the bottom of the stimulus sheet for any words you are not sure of.

Step 2: find and infer

Answer in full sentences. Marks are in brackets.

(a) What job does Dr Pritchard do, and where? (1)

(b) Which type of microbe causes colds and flu? (1)

(c) Why did Mair’s doctors have to switch to a different antibiotic? (1)

(d) List 3 things people do that the article says speed up antibiotic resistance. (3)

(e) Osian says he “used to think the course on the label was more of a suggestion”. What can you infer about how his attitude has changed, and what changed it? (2)

(f) How does Dr Pritchard feel about antibiotic resistance? Quote the words in paragraph 4 that show this. (2)

Step 3: fact, opinion or misleading claim

A fact can be checked and is true. An opinion is a view or a feeling. A misleading claim is written as if it were a fact, but it is false or has no evidence. On the stimulus sheet, highlight the facts in Text B in one colour and the opinions and misleading claims in the other colour. Then complete the table.

TextStatementFact, opinion or misleading claim?
A“antibiotics do not work on viruses”
A“Antibiotic resistance is the most frightening thing I see in my job.”
A“Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin in 1928”
B“Knocks a cold out in 2 days, every time!”
A“in ideal conditions some can divide every 20 minutes”
B“Honestly the best thing I’ve ever done for my health.”
B“a 100% natural antibiotic that kills 99.9% of viruses AND bad bacteria”
A“We are sleepwalking towards a world where a scratched knee could kill.”

(b) Use the science in Text A to explain why Ffion’s claim that antibiotics knock out a cold in 2 days is wrong. (2)

(c) Give 2 reasons why a reader should not trust the claim about ImmunoMax drops. (2)

Step 4: how the writer persuades

Find each technique in Text A. Copy a short quotation (no more than 10 words) and explain its effect on the reader.

Technique (paragraph)QuotationEffect on the reader
Opening with a personal story (1)
A one-sentence paragraph (2)
Quoting an expert (4)
Explaining the science step by step (6)
A rhetorical question (9)
A metaphor (9)

(b) The article begins and ends with Mair. Why do you think the writer organised it this way? (2)

Step 5: compare the 2 texts

Text A: feature articleText B: Ffion’s post
Purpose
Intended audience
Who is speaking, and do they gain anything?
Kind of evidence used
Reliability score (1 = not reliable, 5 = very reliable) and reason

(b) Write one sentence comparing how reliable the 2 texts are. Use whereas or however.

Step 6: extended answer

Work alone and in silence. Answer this question in 3 paragraphs, about 200 to 250 words:

How does the writer of Text A use evidence, structure and language to persuade readers to use antibiotics responsibly?

Use point, evidence, explain (PEE) in every paragraph. Keep quotations short and build them into your own sentences. Name the technique and explain its effect on the reader, not just what it says.

Point: One way the writer persuades readers is by...

Evidence: For example, in paragraph ... the writer says “...”

Explain: This makes the reader feel / realise / trust... because... This persuades them to...

Step 7: the science in 5 sentences

Summarise the science of antibiotic resistance in exactly 5 sentences, in your own words. Sentence 1: bacteria and viruses. Sentence 2: what antibiotics do. Sentence 3: how resistance develops. Sentence 4: what speeds it up. Sentence 5: what everyone should do.

Step by step

  1. 8 min Read Text A, then Text B and its replies.
  2. 6 min Step 2: find information and make inferences.
  3. 8 min Step 3: highlight and sort facts, opinions and misleading claims.
  4. 8 min Step 4: find the techniques the writer uses to persuade.
  5. 6 min Step 5: compare the purpose and reliability of the 2 texts.
  6. 14 min Step 6: write your extended answer, on your own.
  7. 5 min Step 7: summarise the science in 5 sentences.
  8. 3 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early