Cover lesson · Drama · Year 9 · Advanced

Analysing online audience feedback for the school panto

DCF: Data and computational thinking → Data and information literacy

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: judging how far you can trust data collected online, as a theatre company does when it reviews audience feedback. Pupils find the flaws in an online feedback form (a leading question, answer options with no negative choice, and personal data it does not need), work out the mean, median, mode and range of the star ratings, compare the people who answered through a family group chat with those who used the programme QR code, explain why an automatic chart is misleading, and write a recommendation backed by figures. Every calculation must show working. The school, the show and the data are invented.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Sinderela: the online audience feedback form and its results”, one between two. Pupils need a calculator and a ruler. No computers are needed.

Run: 10 min Step 1, judge the form · 12 min Step 2, the star ratings · 10 min Step 3, who answered? · 8 min Step 4, the misleading chart · 10 min Step 5, the recommendation, written alone. Total 50 minutes. Pupils may talk quietly in pairs in Steps 1 to 4.

Collect: this sheet.

Quick checks: Step 1: Q3 is leading and has no negative option; Q6 collects a name, address and phone number the school does not need and forces people to give them. Step 2: total stars 233; mean 3.88; median 4; mode 5; range 4; 4 or 5 stars 70%. Step 3: response rate 17.6%; group chat mean 4.07, QR code mean 3.47. Step 4: the axis starts at 3.7, so a difference of 0.15 stars looks huge. The worked example has every answer and a model recommendation.

What you are doing

Mr Bowen, Head of Drama, is delighted with the feedback from Sinderela: “Nearly 4 stars, and everybody loved the songs!” Before he puts it in the newsletter and plans next year’s show around it, he has asked you to check the data. Is the form fair? What do the numbers really say? Who answered, and who did not?

Key words:

Step 1: judge the form

(a) Find 3 problems with the questions on the form. Say which question, what is wrong, and how it affects the data.

QWhat is wrongHow it affects the data or the people answering

(b) Rewrite Question 3 so that it is fair. Give the new answer options too.

(c) What should Mr Bowen do about Question 6? Explain in one sentence.

Step 2: the star ratings

Use the “All responses” column of Table 1. Show your working.

(a) Total number of stars given (stars × number of people, then add):

 

 

Total stars = __________

(b) Mean rating, to 2 decimal places: ______   (c) Mode: ______   (d) Range: ______

(e) Median: with 60 values in order, the median is halfway between the 30th and 31st values. Count up from 1 star to find them.

 

Median = ______

(f) What percentage of people gave 4 or 5 stars?

 

__________ %

(g) Mr Bowen says “nearly 4 stars”. Which average is he using? Would the median or the mode give a fairer headline? Why?

Step 3: who answered?

(a) Response rate: 60 people answered out of 340 in the audience. What percentage is that, to 1 decimal place?

 

__________ %

(b) Work out the mean star rating for each group in Table 1, to 2 decimal places.

GroupWorkingMean
Family group chat (41)
Programme QR code (19)

(c) Which group’s ratings are more likely to show what the whole audience thought? Give 2 reasons.

(d) The comments mention not hearing from the back. Why might people sitting at the back be less likely to fill in the form at all?

Step 4: the misleading chart

(a) Look at the chart the form tool made. Why does Friday’s bar look so much taller? How big is the real difference?

(b) Sketch a fair version on the axes below. The vertical axis goes from 0 to 5 stars. Label both bars.

0 1 2 3 4 5 Thursday Friday Average stars

(c) Suggest a more honest headline than “Friday blew Thursday away!”

Step 5: your recommendation

Write 100 to 150 words to Mr Bowen. Include:

Words used: ______

Step by step

  1. 10 min Step 1: find 3 problems with the form, rewrite Question 3, decide what to do about Question 6.
  2. 12 min Step 2: work out the total, mean, mode, range, median and percentage for the star ratings.
  3. 10 min Step 3: work out the response rate and the 2 group means, then judge who answered.
  4. 8 min Step 4: explain the misleading chart and sketch a fair one.
  5. 10 min Step 5: write your recommendation on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early