Cover lesson · Art · Year 11 · Advanced

Asking probing questions in an art critique

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Questioning

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: speaking and listening in Art. In groups of 3, pupils run a critique of an invented pupil’s portfolio. The Artist speaks for the pupil on a card and defends their choices; the Questioner asks open, probing questions using a question ladder; the Recorder logs every question and summarises the answers aloud. Roles rotate over 3 rounds, with a new card each round. Giving and receiving feedback in critiques is part of GCSE Art and Design (Made for Wales).

Practice only, not NEA work. The cards describe invented portfolios. Pupils must not discuss their own portfolios.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Ysgol Tanygraig critique: 3 portfolio cards”, one per group of 3.

Set up: put pupils in groups of 3 and let them choose who is A, B and C. A group of 4 adds a second Recorder, who logs the Artist’s answers only. Groups follow the rotation table below.

Signal: at the end of each round, say “Rotate” clearly and raise your hand. Pupils stop, raise their hands and pass roles on. Call out the time halfway through each round (“4 minutes left”).

Run: 8 min Step 1, the question ladder, alone · 5 min Step 2, groups and roles · 8 min Round 1 · 8 min Round 2 · 8 min Round 3 · 8 min Step 4, summary and evaluation, alone · 5 min Step 5, self-assessment. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: every sheet. The Recorder logs in Step 3 are the main evidence: check each pupil completed one.

What you are doing

In a good critique, the questions do the work. “Do you like it?” gets a yes or no. “Why did you crop the hands so close, and how does that help your intention?” makes the artist think and explain. Today you will practise climbing the question ladder, from clarifying to suggesting, and listening carefully enough to summarise what you hear.

The question ladder

RungWhat it doesQuestion starters
4 SuggestOffers an idea, as a question, so the artist can choose.Have you considered…? What would happen if you tried…? Could you…?
3 ChallengeTests a choice politely with another view.Some viewers might say… How would you answer them? Is there a risk that…?
2 ProbeDigs into reasons and links to the intention.Why did you choose…? How does… connect to your intention? What did you learn from…?
1 ClarifyChecks you understand.What do you mean by…? Can you tell me more about…? So are you saying…?

Follow-up rule: after every answer, ask at least one follow-up that uses the artist’s own words: “You said muddy. What caused that?”

Step 1: closed to open

Each question below is closed: it can be answered with one word. Rewrite it as an open, probing question and write its rung (1 to 4).

Closed questionOpen rewriteRung
Do you like your painting?
Is that plaster?
Did you use white on purpose?
Is it finished?
Would colour be better?

Step 2: groups and roles

RoundCardArtistQuestionerRecorder
1MacsenABC
2EfaBCA
3IoanCAB

I am pupil ____. I am the Artist in Round ____, the Questioner in Round ____ and the Recorder in Round ____.

Each round (8 minutes): 2 min everyone reads the card; the Questioner plans. · 5 min the Artist introduces the work in 1 minute, then the Questioner asks at least 4 questions, one from each rung, with follow-ups. · 1 min the Recorder summarises aloud: “So you are saying…”, and the Artist confirms or corrects.

Questioner plan (for the round when you ask): write one question for each rung.

Step 3: Recorder log

Use this in the round when you are Recorder. Keep each note short.

Question askedRungOpen or closedKey point in the answer

Round ____, card ____. Rungs used: 1 ____ 2 ____ 3 ____ 4 ____

Step 4: summary and evaluation

On your own. (a) Summarise in 3 or 4 sentences what the Artist said in the round you recorded: their intention, their problem and what they now plan to do.

(b) Which question in any round was the most useful? Write it out, say which rung it was on, and explain what it made the Artist think about or change.

Step 5: self-assessment

 Not yetMostlyYes
As Artist, I stayed in role and gave reasons for my choices.
As Questioner, I used all 4 rungs and asked follow-ups.
As Recorder, my summary was accurate and the Artist agreed with it.
I challenged politely and responded sensitively to challenge.

One thing I will do differently in my next critique:

Step by step

  1. 8 min Step 1: read the ladder and rewrite the closed questions, alone.
  2. 5 min Step 2: form groups of 3, choose A, B and C, and fill in your roles.
  3. 8 min Round 1: Card 1, Macsen. Rotate on the signal.
  4. 8 min Round 2: Card 2, Efa. Rotate on the signal.
  5. 8 min Round 3: Card 3, Ioan.
  6. 8 min Step 4: write your summary and evaluate the most useful question.
  7. 5 min Step 5: self-assessment.

Success criteria

If you finish early