Cover lesson · Humanities · Year 2 · Advanced
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Questioning
What this practises: asking and answering questions to find out about the past. Pupils spot what was different in a 1950s classroom, learn the question words who, what, where, when and how, write their own questions with a question mark, listen to the answers and give an opinion with a reason. LNF, Year 2: “I am beginning to ask and answer questions to clarify my understanding” and “I can ask and answer questions and exchange ideas and information on topics; I can express opinions, giving reasons, and provide appropriate answers to questions.” Taid Gwyn, his teacher Miss Owen and his village school in Gwynedd are invented for this lesson. The school details (desks with inkwells, dip pens, blackboards, a stove, free milk, playground games, outside toilets) are true of many Welsh village schools in the 1950s.
Print: Part 2 of this sheet (the activity page), one per pupil. The stimulus sheet “Taid Gwyn’s 1958 class photo and answer cards”: page 1 (the photo) to show on the board, or one copy per table; pages 2 and 3 (the 12 answer cards), one set between two, cut up before the lesson if you can (if not, pairs share the uncut sheets), plus one set for you. Pencils. No computers are needed.
Run: 5 min Step 1, meet Taid Gwyn · 8 min Step 2, the old photo, Task 1 · 7 min Step 3, question words, Task 2 · 7 min Step 4, finish the questions, Task 3 · 10 min Step 5, my own questions, Task 4 · 8 min Step 6, Taid answers, Task 5 · 8 min Step 7, paired talk: be Taid · 7 min Step 8, my opinion, Task 6. Total 60 minutes.
Collect: the activity pages. The literacy evidence is Tasks 3, 4 and 6 and the paired talk in Step 7: Task 3 (choosing the right question word and adding a question mark), Task 4 (3 questions of their own, each starting with a question word and ending with a question mark), Task 6 (an opinion with a reason using because), and the paired talk (tick the 3 teacher boxes at the bottom of each page as you listen). Answers, Task 1: any 3 of the blackboard and chalk, the wooden desks in rows with inkwell holes, the stove with its tall pipe and guard, the crate of little milk bottles. Task 2: who, the teacher; what, the milk bottle; where, the school; when, the calendar; how, the footprints walking to school. Task 3: “Who was your teacher?” and “When did you start school?” Tasks 4 and 6 have many right answers.
Read the words in the boxes aloud. Show the photo from the stimulus sheet, or point to the photo in Task 1 on the activity page.
Say: “This is a picture of Taid Gwyn’s class at school. Taid is a word for grandad that lots of people use in North Wales. Taid Gwyn is not a real person. We made him up for this lesson, but the things in his school are true about schools long ago. Gwyn started at his village school in Gwynedd, in North Wales, in September 1958, when he was 5 years old. That is about 70 years ago. Can you find Gwyn? He is in the front row.”
Ask: “Is this picture from now or from long ago? How can you tell?” (It is black and white; it says 1958 on the board; the desks look old.)
Not every pupil has a grandparent they can ask. Today Taid Gwyn is everyone’s pretend Taid.
Say: “Look very carefully at Taid Gwyn’s classroom. Find 3 things that are different from our classroom today. Draw a ring round each one.”
Ask: “What did you ring? What do we have now instead?” Expected answers: the blackboard (now a whiteboard or a screen); the wooden desks in rows, 2 children at each desk (now tables in groups); the stove with a tall pipe and a metal guard to keep the room warm (now radiators); the crate of little milk bottles (now water bottles or fruit).
Say: “Look at the little round holes in the desks. They held inkwells, small pots of ink. Older children dipped a pen in the ink to write. Younger children like Gwyn used pencils.”
Say: “Historians find out about the past by asking questions. Good questions often start with a question word. Say them with me: who, what, where, when, how. Who asks about a person. What asks about a thing. Where asks about a place. When asks about a time. How asks about the way something happens.”
Say: “In Task 2, draw a line from each question word to the picture it goes with. The small words next to the pictures will help you.”
Ask: “Which question word would find out the name of Taid’s teacher?” (Who.) “Which word would find out the year he started school?” (When.) Answers: who, teacher; what, milk bottle; where, school; when, calendar; how, footprints.
Say: “This is a question mark. Every question ends with one. Read each question in Task 3. Choose the right question word from the 2 boxes and write it in the gap. Then write a question mark in the box at the end.”
Ask: “Why is it not ‘Where was your teacher?’” (Where asks about a place, and we want to know a person.) Answers: Who was your teacher? When did you start school?
Say: “Now you are the historian. Write 3 questions you would like to ask Taid Gwyn about his school. Start each one with a question word and a capital letter. End each one with a question mark. If you are stuck, look at the idea pictures.”
Model one on the board: How did you get to school? Then rub it out so pupils think of their own. Walk round. Check each question starts with a question word and ends with a question mark. Pupils who find writing hard can say their question to you first, then write it; choosing a question word and an idea picture helps.
Say: “Now I am going to be Taid Gwyn. Put your hand up and read me one of your questions.”
Find the card with the same or closest question and read Taid’s answer in a friendly voice. Take 8 to 10 questions, so the class hears most cards, including the milk, the stove, the inkwell and the toilets. If no card answers a question, say as Taid: “I don’t remember that. Ask me another question!”
Say: “If Taid answered one of your questions, tick its box in Task 5. If not, that is fine: historians often ask questions that nobody can answer yet. Now draw 1 new thing you found out about Taid’s school, and write a word or two about it.”
Say: “One of you is Taid Gwyn and holds the cards. The other one asks Taid questions from Task 4, or new ones. Taid, find the card with the same question and read the answer in your best Taid voice. Then Taid asks: ‘Would you like to go to my school? Why?’ Answer with because. After 4 minutes, swap.”
Walk round and listen. For each pupil, tick the teacher boxes at the bottom of the activity page: asked a clear question, answered as Taid using a card, gave a reason with because. Pupils may tick more boxes in Task 5 if their partner’s cards answered them.
Say: “Would you like to go to school long ago? Ring would or would not. Then finish the sentence with your reason after because. Both answers are fine. Your reason is the important part.”
Model 2 on the board: I would like school long ago because you got free milk every day. I would not like school long ago because the toilets were outside and cold. In the last 2 minutes, ask 3 pupils to read their sentence aloud, then read the “I can” boxes; pupils tick the ones they agree with.
Name: Date:
was your teacher
did you start school
Start with a question word. End with a question mark ?
Ideas to ask about:
Draw 1 new thing you found out about Taid’s school.
Teacher, paired talk (Step 7): asked a clear question answered as Taid using a card gave a reason with “because”