Cover lesson · PE · Year 8 · Intermediate

Comparing media coverage of two cup finals

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: close reading and comparison of texts about sport. GCSE Physical Education and Health (Made for Wales) Unit 1, section 1.1.2 asks pupils to study socio-cultural influences on participation, including media coverage and role models, “from a variety of perspectives”. Pupils compare an invented newspaper’s reports of a men’s and a women’s rugby final: they find facts, analyse word choices, write a comparison and rewrite a report fairly. This is a reading lesson: no rugby knowledge is needed, and nobody exercises today.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “The Cwm Courier: two cup finals, two reports”, one between two. Pupils need two different coloured highlighters or pencils. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min read the three texts in pairs, one reading aloud · 8 min Step 2, find the facts · 10 min Step 3, word hunt · 10 min Step 4, analyse three quotations · 12 min Step 5, the comparison paragraph, alone · 10 min Step 6, rewrite the report. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has the answers. If pupils ask whether this is real: the paper, clubs and players are invented, but the patterns in the language are ones researchers have found in real sports coverage.

What you are doing

The media shape how people think about sport and who they think sport is for. Two Pontglas teams won cup finals on the same day, on the same pitch. The local paper reported both. You are going to read the reports like a detective: what does each one tell the reader, what words does it choose, and is the coverage fair?

Step 1: read the texts

Read Texts A, B and C with your partner. One of you reads aloud. Check the rugby words at the bottom of the sheet if you need them.

Step 2: find the facts

 Text A: men’s finalText B: women’s final
Where in the paper?
Length in words
What the photo shows
Final score
How many players are named?
Are players’ positions given?
Who is quoted?
Does it explain how the game was won?

Which team won by more points? Use Text C: what facts about the women’s final are missing from Text B?

Step 3: word hunt

Highlight every word or phrase that describes the players or teams in Texts A and B. Then sort them. Skill and performance means what they did in the game. Appearance, family or feelings means anything else.

 Skill and performanceAppearance, family or feelings
Text A
Text B

What pattern do you notice?

Step 4: analyse three quotations

For each quotation, explain what the words suggest and what effect they might have on a reader. Compare with Text A where you can.

QuotationWhat it suggestsEffect on the reader
“the Pontglas girls” and “ladies”
“a pretty hat-trick” compared with “smashed through three tackles”
“before the main game”

Step 5: write a comparison

On your own. Answer this question in 100 to 150 words: How fairly does The Cwm Courier report the two finals?

Step 6: rewrite the report

You are the sports editor. Rewrite the headline and the first 3 sentences of Text B so that the women’s final is reported in the same way as the men’s. Use facts from Text C. Describe what the players did, not how they look.

Headline:  

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the three texts with your partner.
  2. 8 min Fill in the facts table.
  3. 10 min Highlight and sort the describing words.
  4. 10 min Analyse the three quotations.
  5. 12 min Write your comparison on your own.
  6. 10 min Rewrite the headline and opening of Text B.

Success criteria

If you finish early