Cover lesson · Art · Year 10 · Intermediate

Comparing two landscapes from different times: Cwm Tawelan

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: reading and analysis in Art. Pupils read detailed written descriptions of two invented artworks of the same Welsh valley, one painted in 1893 for a quarry owner and one printed in 2019 by a local artist. They pick out evidence, analyse each work under content, form, process and mood, work out how context (who paid, who it was for, what is left out) shapes meaning, separate facts from interpretations, and write a comparative paragraph and a judgement. Analysing how context shapes meaning is central to AO1 in GCSE Art and Design (Made for Wales).

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Two landscapes of Cwm Tawelan: 1893 and 2019”, one per pupil. Pupils need a pen. No images or computers are needed: the artworks are described in words. Everything about them is invented, so pupils cannot look them up.

Run: 9 min Step 1, read and mark the evidence · 10 min Step 2, the analysis grid · 8 min Step 3, context · 5 min Step 4, fact or interpretation · 12 min Step 5, comparative paragraph, alone · 6 min Step 6, your judgement. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet, for the class teacher to check against the worked example. Practice only: this is not NEA work.

What you are doing

Two artists looked at the same valley from the same hill, 126 years apart, and made very different pictures. Neither picture is simply “what was there”. Each artist chose what to show, how to show it and what to leave out, and those choices depend on who the work was for. Today you will read both artworks closely and explain how their context shapes their meaning.

Step 1: read and mark the evidence

Read both descriptions and both context panels on the stimulus sheet. Mark them with these symbols (or 4 highlighter colours):

MarkHeadingLook for
underlineContentWhat is shown: people, places, objects, subject matter.
circleFormColour, line, shape, composition, focal point, surface.
boxProcessMaterials and how the work was made.
wavy lineMoodThe feeling or atmosphere, and words that create it.

List 3 things that were really in the valley in 1893 but are not shown in Artwork A.

Step 2: the analysis grid

Write short notes, and quote at least one detail from the stimulus in every box.

 A: Harvest in Cwm Tawelan (1893)B: Llyn y Twll (2019)
Content
Form
Process
Mood

Step 3: context shapes meaning

QuestionArtwork A (1893)Artwork B (2019)
Who paid for it?
Who was it made for? Where was it shown?
What is left out?
Why, do you think?

The oak trees appear in both artworks. Explain what they mean in each one.

Step 4: fact or interpretation?

Write F if the statement is a fact given in the stimulus, or I if it is an interpretation (someone’s reading or opinion). For one I, write the evidence someone could use to support it.

 StatementF or I
1Artwork A was paid for by the owner of the quarry.
2Arthur Hale hid the quarry because he was ashamed of it.
3The pit in Artwork B is printed in acid turquoise.
4The plastic in Artwork B makes the valley look like a rubbish tip.
5Sheep still graze in the valley today.
6Artwork B is more truthful than Artwork A.

Step 5: comparative paragraph

On your own. Answer: Compare how the two artists show the quarry in Cwm Tawelan. Write one paragraph of about 120 words using this structure.

Step 6: your judgement

“Seren’s print is a more honest picture of Cwm Tawelan than Hale’s painting.” How far do you agree? Write 4 or 5 sentences. Use evidence from both artworks, and consider what both artists leave out.

Step by step

  1. 9 min Step 1: read both artworks and mark content, form, process and mood.
  2. 10 min Step 2: complete the analysis grid for both artworks.
  3. 8 min Step 3: explain how context shapes meaning.
  4. 5 min Step 4: sort facts from interpretations.
  5. 12 min Step 5: write your comparative paragraph on your own.
  6. 6 min Step 6: write your judgement.

Success criteria

If you finish early