Cover lesson · Music · Year 8 · Intermediate

Comparing two versions of a folk song: Ar Lan y Môr

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: literacy in Music: using connectives to link and compare ideas, and varying sentence structure. Pupils sort connectives by purpose, join simple sentences into compound and complex ones, improve a paragraph that only uses “and” and “but”, then write a three-paragraph comparison of two versions of a Welsh folk song using musical terms. This builds towards GCSE Music (Made for Wales), Unit 3: Appraising, where pupils write extended answers that compare pieces.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Ar Lan y Môr: listening notes on two versions”, one between two. Nothing needs to be played: the two versions are invented and described in the listening notes.

Run: 6 min pupils read the stimulus sheet · 6 min Step 1, sorting connectives · 10 min Step 2, joining sentences · 8 min Step 3, improving Siôn’s paragraph · 5 min Step 4, planning · 17 min Step 5, writing · 3 min Step 6, checking. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet, for the class teacher to check against the worked example.

What you are doing

When you compare two pieces of music, the small linking words matter as much as the musical terms. Connectives such as whereas, similarly and as a result tell the reader whether you are showing a difference, a similarity or an effect. Today you will learn to choose the right connective for the job and use it to write a clear comparison.

Step 1: sort the connectives

Sort every connective from section 4 of the stimulus sheet into the right group. Some can go in more than one group; choose the best one.

GroupConnectives
Showing a difference (contrast)
Showing a similarity
Showing cause and effect
Adding another point
Showing order in time

Step 2: join the sentences

Join each pair into one sentence with the connective given. Change or remove words if you need to, and punctuate carefully (read the tip in section 4).

 Two simple sentencesOne linked sentence
1Version 1 is slow, at about 66 BPM. Version 2 is faster, at about 112 BPM. (whereas)
2Version 1 is mostly quiet. It sounds calm and private. (as a result)
3Version 1 is in a major key. Version 2 is in a major key. (both)
4Version 2 adds drum kit, bass, electric guitar and synth. Its texture is much thicker. (because)
5Version 2 modulates up a tone for the last verse. Version 1 stays in one key. (however)
6Lowri Haf uses rubato. She can slow down on important words. (which means that)

Look at sentence 4. Could you start the sentence with Because? Rewrite it that way, with the comma in the right place.

Step 3: improve Siôn’s paragraph

Read Siôn’s paragraph in section 3. Count how many times he uses and:       but:       then:      

Rewrite it. Keep his ideas, but: use at least four different connectives from at least three groups; replace “the first one” and “the second one” with the performers’ names; add at least two musical terms from the listening notes.

Step 4: plan your comparison

Compare the two versions of Ar Lan y Môr. Which one suits the words of the song better?

ParagraphElementsKey similarity or difference, and the connective I will use
1Tempo and dynamics
2Texture and timbre
3Structure and tonality, then my judgement

Step 5: write your comparison

Write three paragraphs, 200 to 250 words in total. Use at least six different connectives from at least three groups, and at least one sentence that starts with a connective. End by saying which version suits the words better, and why.

Step 6: check your writing

Step by step

  1. 6 min Read the listening notes, Siôn’s paragraph and the connectives.
  2. 6 min Step 1: sort the connectives.
  3. 10 min Step 2: join the six pairs of sentences.
  4. 8 min Step 3: rewrite Siôn’s paragraph.
  5. 5 min Step 4: plan your three paragraphs.
  6. 17 min Step 5: write your comparison.
  7. 3 min Step 6: check your connectives, terms and commas.

Success criteria

If you finish early