Cover lesson · RE · Year 9 · Intermediate

Comparing views on wealth: Christian, Sikh and humanist

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “What should we do with money? Three perspectives”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need three different coloured highlighters or pencils.

Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 8 min Step 2, key terms · 12 min Step 3, comparison table · 7 min Step 4, whose view is it? · 6 min Step 5, similarities and differences · 12 min Step 6, writing a paragraph alone. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: reading three texts to identify different viewpoints, collecting information from them under headings, and comparing them in writing. It prepares pupils for GCSE Religious Studies, where every Unit 3 topic ends with the similarities and differences between religious and non-religious perspectives. Pupils do not have to agree with any view.

What you are doing

Is it wrong to be rich? What should we do with our money? You will read what many Christians, Sikhs and humanists believe, collect their views in a table, work out who is speaking from clues in what they say, and then write a paragraph comparing two of the views.

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read the three perspectives. Highlight each one in a different colour. Do not read the six people yet.

Step 2: key terms

Use the stimulus to explain each term in your own words, in no more than 10 words.

TermMeaning in my own words
Stewardship (Christian)
Tithing (Christian)
Kirat Karni (Sikh)
Vand Chhakna (Sikh)
Langar (Sikh)
Empathy (humanist)

Step 3: collect the views

Fill in the table in short notes. Use the stimulus, not what you guess.

QuestionChristianSikhHumanist
Is being rich wrong?
How should money be earned or treated?
What should people do with their money?
Where does the view come from?

Step 4: whose view is it?

Now read the six people at the end of the stimulus. For each one, decide whether they are most likely Christian, Sikh or humanist. Give the clue word or phrase that told you. One of them could belong to more than one group: say which, and why.

PersonMost likelyClue from what they say
1
2
3
4
5
6

Step 5: similarities and differences

(a) Give 2 things that all three perspectives agree on.

(b) Give 2 important differences between them.

Step 6: write a comparison

Choose two of the three perspectives. In about 120 words, explain the most important difference between their views on wealth. Include:

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read and highlight the three perspectives with a partner.
  2. 8 min Step 2: explain the key terms in your own words.
  3. 12 min Step 3: collect the views in the table.
  4. 7 min Step 4: match the six people to a perspective, with clues.
  5. 6 min Step 5: similarities and differences.
  6. 12 min Step 6: your comparison paragraph, on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early