Cover lesson · Music · Year 7 · Beginner

Designing a survey of music listening habits

LNF: Numeracy → Statistics and probability → Collecting data

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: collecting data in Music. The Music department at Ysgol Bro Alaw, an invented Welsh school, wants to know how Year 7 listen to music before it plans a lunchtime club. Pupils choose a testable hypothesis, sort types of data, fix 8 faulty survey questions, design a 6-question questionnaire, plan a fair sample, then tally 30 invented completed questionnaires and decide whether the hypothesis is supported. No music is played.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Year 7 music survey: 30 completed questionnaires”, one between two. Pupils need a pen, a pencil and a ruler.

Run: 4 min Step 1, hypothesis · 6 min Step 2, types of data · 12 min Step 3, fix the questions · 10 min Step 4, your questionnaire · 6 min Step 5, who to ask · 4 min Step 6, draw a tally table · 10 min Step 7, collect the data · 5 min Step 8, is the hypothesis supported? Total 57 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The numbers to check first: every frequency table in Step 7 must total 30, and Q1 should give A 5, B 11, C 9, D 5. Only 14 pupils listen for more than 1 hour, so the hypothesis is not supported. All answers are on the worked example sheet.

What you are doing

Mrs Gwilym, Head of Music, wants to start a lunchtime music club for Year 7. She needs facts, not guesses, and a survey only gives facts if the questions are fair, the answer boxes work and the right people are asked. Today you design a survey, then test a hypothesis with answers from 30 pupils.

Step 1: question or hypothesis?

A hypothesis is a statement that data can show to be true or false. Tick the 2 hypotheses.

(a) Today we test the second statement. If 30 pupils answer, “most” means at least ______ pupils. Why?

(b) Write your own hypothesis about how Year 7 listen to music.

Step 2: what type of data?

Qualitative data is words or categories, such as a colour. Quantitative data is numbers. It is discrete if it is counted and can only be certain values, such as 3 brothers. It is continuous if it is measured and can be any value in a range, such as 1.37 metres.

Write each letter in the correct column. There are 3 in each column. (a) has been done for you.

(a) favourite style of music · (b) number of songs in a pupil’s favourite playlist · (c) time spent listening to music yesterday · (d) number of instruments a pupil can play · (e) how a pupil listens most often (app, radio, CD) · (f) length of the school song, timed with a stopwatch · (g) number of concerts a pupil went to last year · (h) what a pupil would like to do at the club · (i) how long a pupil can hold a sung note

QualitativeQuantitative: discreteQuantitative: continuous
(a)

(j) Time is continuous, but Q1 on the stimulus sheet puts it into 4 boxes. Give one reason why.

Step 3: fix the faulty questions

L leading: pushes people towards one answer · O overlapping boxes: one answer fits 2 boxes · G gaps: some answers fit no box · T two questions in one · V vague words such as often, a lot, regularly · P personal data the survey does not need

Write the fault letter or letters, then rewrite the question with better answer boxes. Question 1 has been done for you.

No.Faulty questionFaultBetter version, with answer boxes
1Don’t you agree that a lunchtime music club would be brilliant? Yes · NoLWould you come to a lunchtime music club? Yes · Maybe · No
2How long do you spend listening to music on a school day? 0 to 1 hour · 1 to 2 hours · 2 to 3 hours
3How many songs did you listen to yesterday? 1 to 10 · 15 to 25 · 30 or more
4Do you play an instrument and would you come to the club? Yes · No
5Do you listen to music a lot? Yes · No
6Do you go to concerts regularly? Yes · No
7Write your full name, date of birth and home address.
8Which style of music do you like? Pop · Rock

Step 4: design your questionnaire

Write 6 questions for Mrs Gwilym. No names; one question must test the hypothesis; number boxes must not overlap or leave gaps; add “Other” where needed; include quantitative and qualitative questions.

No.QuestionAnswer boxesType of data
1
2
3
4
5
6

Box test: for your time question, which box would each of these go in? Each must fit exactly one box.

0 minutes ______ · 30 minutes ______ · 1 hour ______ · 61 minutes ______ · 3 hours ______

Step 5: who will you ask?

Year 7 has 120 pupils in 4 forms of 30.

(a) How many pupils will you ask? What percentage of Year 7 is that? Show your working.

(b) How will you choose them so that every Year 7 pupil has the same chance of being asked?

(c) Give 2 reasons why you should not just ask your friends.

Step 6: draw a tally table

With a ruler, draw a tally and frequency table for Q1 on the stimulus sheet. Use 3 columns headed Time on a school day, Tally and Frequency. Write each box in full (not just A to D), one per row, and add a Total row.

Step 7: collect the data

Go down the 30 questionnaires once for each question. Tally in bundles of 5 (|||| with a line across). Fill in your Step 6 table for Q1, then these tables for Q2 and Q5. Each table must total 30.

How they listen (Q2)TallyFreq.Come to club? (Q5)TallyFreq.
Streaming appYes
Video websiteMaybe
RadioNo
CD or vinyl|1Total
Other
Total

Step 8: is the hypothesis supported?

(a) Which Q1 boxes mean “more than 1 hour”? How many pupils ticked them? Show the sum.

(b) Write that number as a fraction of 30 in its simplest form. Is it more than half?

(c) Is the hypothesis “Most Year 7 pupils listen to music for more than 1 hour on a school day” supported? Quote numbers, and give one reason the answer might not be the full picture.

(d) 30 is 1 in every 4 of Year 7. Use Q5 to estimate how many of the 120 pupils would say Yes to the club. Show your working.

Step by step

  1. 4 min Step 1: tick the hypotheses and write your own.
  2. 6 min Step 2: sort the 9 examples into types of data.
  3. 12 min Step 3: name the fault in each question and rewrite it.
  4. 10 min Step 4: write your 6 questions, then do the box test.
  5. 6 min Step 5: plan who to ask.
  6. 4 min Step 6: draw the tally table with a ruler.
  7. 10 min Step 7: tally Q1, Q2 and Q5. Check each total is 30.
  8. 5 min Step 8: decide if the hypothesis is supported.

Success criteria

If you finish early