Cover lesson · Design Technology · Year 11 · Advanced
DCF: Data and computational thinking → Data and information literacy
Name: Class: Date:
What this practises: GCSE Design and Technology (Made-for-Wales, teaching from 2026), Unit 2: Design Project, 2.1.6 Analysing and evaluating design decisions and prototypes: making informed judgements, acting on the views of others, and suggesting modifications. It uses an invented pupil’s project about a jar opener. This is practice only, not NEA work. Pupils must not use this lesson to work on their own design project, and nothing they write today goes into their NEA folder.
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “The Gafael jar opener: prototype test pack”, one between two. Calculators needed. The user trial is also in gafael-user-trial.csv if you are in a computer room, but paper is fine.
Run: 7 min pupils read the test pack in pairs · 15 min Step 2, the calculations and specification check · 8 min Step 3, test Elin’s claim · 7 min Step 4, how reliable is the evidence · 12 min Step 5, the evaluation, alone and in silence · 6 min Step 6, modifications. Total 55 minutes.
Collect: this sheet. The class teacher has a worked example and answer key.
Elin has designed and made a prototype jar opener for older people with arthritis. She has tested it in the workshop and with 10 users, and she has written a draft conclusion. You are going to check her data, test every specification point, decide how far the evidence can be trusted, and then write the evaluation she should have written, with modifications that come from the evidence.
Key words:
Read all six sections. Highlight every figure you could use as evidence.
(a) How many of the 10 users opened the jar with the opener? How many opened it without?
(b) Three users have “not opened” for the time without. You cannot average “not opened”. Work out the mean time without and with, using only the 7 users who opened the jar both ways. By what percentage did the opener cut the time? Give answers to 1 decimal place.
(c) Work out the mean comfort rating for all 10 users. Then work it out for the 8 users who have arthritis only.
(d) Work out the material cost of one opener, using the masses and prices in section 4.
(e) Now judge every point. Every evidence cell needs a figure or a quotation.
| Point | Evidence | Met, partly met or not met |
|---|---|---|
| S1 | ||
| S2 | ||
| S3 | ||
| S4 | ||
| S5 | ||
| S6 | ||
| S7 | ||
| S8 | ||
| S9 |
Elin wrote: “My jar opener works for everyone and makes opening jars twice as fast. All 10 users liked it. It meets my specification.”
Take each of her four claims in turn. Say whether the data supports it, and use a figure. Then rewrite her conclusion so that it is true.
My rewritten conclusion:
Find three things about how Elin collected her data that make it less reliable or less valid. For each one, say how she should do it next time.
| Problem with how the data was collected | Better method | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||
| 2 | ||
| 3 |
On your own, in silence. Write 150 to 200 words: How well does the Gafael jar opener meet the needs of Mrs Hughes and other older people with arthritis? Use at least three figures and one user quotation. Give strengths as well as weaknesses, and end with a clear overall judgement.
Three modifications. Each must answer a problem you have evidence for, say how Elin could make the change, and say how she will test it.
| Problem and evidence | Modification and how to make it | How to test it | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 |