Cover lesson · Science · Year 9 · Advanced

Evaluating online claims about sports recovery drinks

DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content

Also assessed, LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: evaluating the credibility, method and funding bias of online health claims (DCF), alongside calculating percentage changes, checking nutrition data and exposing a misleading truncated graph axis (LNF numeracy: interpreting data).

Board: open the supply teacher presentation (/cover-lesson-resources/presentations/evaluating-online-claims-about-sports-recovery-drinks.html) for board slides, countdown timers and a spoken script.

Print: this worksheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “HydraMax Pro: viral fitness post versus laboratory trial”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need a calculator.

Run: 5 min settling starter · 5 min brief and key vocabulary · 10 min Step 1, auditing the two trials · 10 min Step 2, percentage change and sugar calculations · 12 min Step 3 and Step 4, exposing the truncated graph and writing the fact-check post · 5 min partner/self check against success criteria · 3 min plenary quick-check. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this worksheet. Quick checks: sample size is 6 vs 60; real sprint time improvements are 1.0% (water), 1.8% (squash) and 2.0% (HydraMax Pro); one 500 ml bottle contains 36.0 g of sugar (120% of the 30 g NHS daily limit) and costs 20 times more than diluted squash (£2.80 vs £0.14); Graph A’s truncated y-axis starting at 49.6 s makes the HydraMax bar 5 times taller (50 mm vs 10 mm).

What you are doing

A fitness influencer, @FitWithRhys_CW, has posted a viral advert claiming that HydraMax Pro Berry Blast gives athletes “40% faster recovery”. Your school sports council has been asked whether to stock HydraMax Pro in the gym vending machine at £2.80 a bottle. Using the stimulus sheet, you will compare the influencer’s test against an independent university laboratory trial, check the percentage and nutrition maths, expose a misleading bar chart, and write an evidence-based science fact-check post.

Step 1: audit the method and credibility

Use Sections 1 and 2 of the stimulus sheet to compare the influencer’s gym mini-test with the Cardiff Sports Science Laboratory trial.

(a) Complete the audit table below. The first row has been started for you on the board.

Feature Influencer post (Section 1) University lab trial (Section 2) Why this affects validity or reliability
Sample size
Control group
Funding and independence
How recovery was measured

(b) In the university laboratory trial, all three drinks were flavoured with sugar-free berry drops and served in identical opaque bottles so neither the runners nor the timers knew who drank what. Explain why this double-blind method prevents the placebo effect.

Step 2: check the percentage change and nutrition data

Use Sections 1, 2 and 3 of the stimulus sheet. Show your working clearly for every question.

Formula: percentage change = (change ÷ original value) × 100

(a) In the influencer’s post, the 6 gym members’ self-rated energy score rose from 5.0 to 7.0 (an increase of 2.0 points out of 5.0, which is 40%). Now complete the table below for the objective 400 m sprint times in the 60-runner laboratory trial.

Drink group (20 runners each) Baseline mean (s) Recovery mean (s) Time saved (s) Percentage improvement (%)
Group A: Plain water 50.0 49.5 0.5 (0.5 ÷ 50.0) × 100 = 1.0%
Group B: Diluted orange squash + salt 50.0 49.1
Group C: HydraMax Pro Berry Blast 50.0 49.0

(b) Look at the nutrition table in Section 3. HydraMax Pro lists 7.2 g of sugar per 100 ml, and Homemade diluted squash lists 4.4 g of sugar per 100 ml. Calculate the total mass of sugar in one 500 ml bottle of each drink, and work out what percentage of the NHS 30 g daily free-sugar limit one bottle of HydraMax Pro provides.

(c) How many times more expensive is one 500 ml bottle of HydraMax Pro (£2.80) than 500 ml of homemade diluted squash with a pinch of salt (£0.14)? Does the laboratory data justify paying this extra cost?

Step 3: expose the misleading bar chart

Look at Graph A and Graph B in Section 4 of the stimulus sheet.

(a) Complete the comparison table below to show how the truncated vertical axis on Graph A distorts the laboratory results.

Feature Graph A (Promotional chart) Graph B (Honest scientific chart)
Y-axis starting value
Water bar height vs HydraMax bar height (mm)
How many times taller does the HydraMax bar look?

(b) Besides truncating the vertical axis, identify one other way the creators of Graph A hid inconvenient evidence from buyers.

Step 4: write your science fact-check post

Write a 100 to 140 word reply for the school sports council noticeboard evaluating @FitWithRhys_CW’s post. Follow the 4-part structure: (1) Headline verdict, (2) Method and bias flaws (sample size, control group, #Ad commission), (3) Real sprint numbers and graph distortion, and (4) Final recommendation using the sugar and cost figures.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Settling starter: read Section 1 of the stimulus sheet and spot two warning signs in the fine print.
  2. 5 min Read Sections 2, 3 and 4 of the stimulus sheet and review the five key words.
  3. 10 min Step 1: complete the method and credibility audit table and explain the double-blind control.
  4. 10 min Step 2: calculate the sprint percentage improvements, 500 ml sugar totals, and cost ratio.
  5. 12 min Step 3 and Step 4: analyse Graph A versus Graph B, then write your 100 to 140 word science fact-check post.
  6. 5 min Check your worksheet against the success criteria below and tick each box you have met.
  7. 3 min Plenary: check your numerical answers against the board before handing in your sheet.

Success criteria

If you finish early