Cover lesson · Science · Year 9 · Advanced
DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content
Also assessed, LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data
Name: Class: Date:
What this practises: evaluating the credibility, method and funding bias of online health claims (DCF), alongside calculating percentage changes, checking nutrition data and exposing a misleading truncated graph axis (LNF numeracy: interpreting data).
Board: open the supply teacher presentation (/cover-lesson-resources/presentations/evaluating-online-claims-about-sports-recovery-drinks.html) for board slides, countdown timers and a spoken script.
Print: this worksheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “HydraMax Pro: viral fitness post versus laboratory trial”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need a calculator.
Run: 5 min settling starter · 5 min brief and key vocabulary · 10 min Step 1, auditing the two trials · 10 min Step 2, percentage change and sugar calculations · 12 min Step 3 and Step 4, exposing the truncated graph and writing the fact-check post · 5 min partner/self check against success criteria · 3 min plenary quick-check. Total 50 minutes.
Collect: this worksheet. Quick checks: sample size is 6 vs 60; real sprint time improvements are 1.0% (water), 1.8% (squash) and 2.0% (HydraMax Pro); one 500 ml bottle contains 36.0 g of sugar (120% of the 30 g NHS daily limit) and costs 20 times more than diluted squash (£2.80 vs £0.14); Graph A’s truncated y-axis starting at 49.6 s makes the HydraMax bar 5 times taller (50 mm vs 10 mm).
A fitness influencer, @FitWithRhys_CW, has posted a viral advert claiming that HydraMax Pro Berry Blast gives athletes “40% faster recovery”. Your school sports council has been asked whether to stock HydraMax Pro in the gym vending machine at £2.80 a bottle. Using the stimulus sheet, you will compare the influencer’s test against an independent university laboratory trial, check the percentage and nutrition maths, expose a misleading bar chart, and write an evidence-based science fact-check post.
Use Sections 1 and 2 of the stimulus sheet to compare the influencer’s gym mini-test with the Cardiff Sports Science Laboratory trial.
(a) Complete the audit table below. The first row has been started for you on the board.
| Feature | Influencer post (Section 1) | University lab trial (Section 2) | Why this affects validity or reliability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample size | |||
| Control group | |||
| Funding and independence | |||
| How recovery was measured |
(b) In the university laboratory trial, all three drinks were flavoured with sugar-free berry drops and served in identical opaque bottles so neither the runners nor the timers knew who drank what. Explain why this double-blind method prevents the placebo effect.
Use Sections 1, 2 and 3 of the stimulus sheet. Show your working clearly for every question.
Formula: percentage change = (change ÷ original value) × 100
(a) In the influencer’s post, the 6 gym members’ self-rated energy score rose from 5.0 to 7.0 (an increase of 2.0 points out of 5.0, which is 40%). Now complete the table below for the objective 400 m sprint times in the 60-runner laboratory trial.
| Drink group (20 runners each) | Baseline mean (s) | Recovery mean (s) | Time saved (s) | Percentage improvement (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Group A: Plain water | 50.0 | 49.5 | 0.5 | (0.5 ÷ 50.0) × 100 = 1.0% |
| Group B: Diluted orange squash + salt | 50.0 | 49.1 | ||
| Group C: HydraMax Pro Berry Blast | 50.0 | 49.0 |
(b) Look at the nutrition table in Section 3. HydraMax Pro lists 7.2 g of sugar per 100 ml, and Homemade diluted squash lists 4.4 g of sugar per 100 ml. Calculate the total mass of sugar in one 500 ml bottle of each drink, and work out what percentage of the NHS 30 g daily free-sugar limit one bottle of HydraMax Pro provides.
(c) How many times more expensive is one 500 ml bottle of HydraMax Pro (£2.80) than 500 ml of homemade diluted squash with a pinch of salt (£0.14)? Does the laboratory data justify paying this extra cost?
Look at Graph A and Graph B in Section 4 of the stimulus sheet.
(a) Complete the comparison table below to show how the truncated vertical axis on Graph A distorts the laboratory results.
| Feature | Graph A (Promotional chart) | Graph B (Honest scientific chart) |
|---|---|---|
| Y-axis starting value | ||
| Water bar height vs HydraMax bar height (mm) | ||
| How many times taller does the HydraMax bar look? |
(b) Besides truncating the vertical axis, identify one other way the creators of Graph A hid inconvenient evidence from buyers.
Write a 100 to 140 word reply for the school sports council noticeboard evaluating @FitWithRhys_CW’s post. Follow the 4-part structure: (1) Headline verdict, (2) Method and bias flaws (sample size, control group, #Ad commission), (3) Real sprint numbers and graph distortion, and (4) Final recommendation using the sugar and cost figures.