Cover lesson · History · Year 9 · Advanced

Evaluating Tone and Purpose in Two Accounts of the Rebecca Riots

LNF: Writing → Purpose · DCF: Producing → Sourcing, searching and planning digital content

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: pupils compare two contrasting 1843 primary accounts of the Rebecca Riots in Carmarthenshire (a magistrate’s letter to the Home Office vs a Welsh tenant farmer’s petition), calculate the percentage of weekly income spent on road tolls, evaluate digital search queries, and write a balanced historical explanation.

Board: open the supply teacher presentation (/cover-lesson-resources/presentations/evaluating-tone-and-purpose-in-two-accounts-of-the-rebecca-riots.html) for board slides, built-in timers and spoken script.

Print: this worksheet (one per pupil) and the stimulus sheet “The Rebecca Riots (1843): Two Contrasting Accounts and Turnpike Toll Table” (one between two). No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min settling starter · 5 min audience, purpose and tone · 10 min Step 1 source comparison · 10 min Step 2 toll percentage calculations and search query check · 12 min Step 3 two-sided historical explanation · 5 min Step 4 objective rewrite · 3 min plenary review. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this named worksheet at the end of the lesson. Keep stimulus sheets for reuse.

Quick checks: Step 2(a) weekly toll costs out of 120d income: Lime = 48d (40%), Market = 18d (15%), Coal = 24d (20%); Total weekly tolls = 90d (75% of weekly income), leaving just 30d (2 shillings and 6 pence) for food and clothes.

What you are doing

In 1843, disguised Carmarthenshire farmers known as Merched Beca (Rebecca and her Daughters) attacked turnpike tollgates that charged repeated fees on carts of lime, coal and farm produce. You will compare two primary sources written in 1843 for very different audiences and purposes, calculate the percentage of a farmer’s weekly income swallowed by road tolls, check how historians search digital archives, and write a balanced two-sided explanation.

Key words

Step 1: Compare audience, purpose, tone and vocabulary in Sources A and B

Read Section 2 of the stimulus sheet and complete the comparison table below. Quote exact words from both sources.

Feature Source A: Colonel Henry Wyndham, J.P. (19 June 1843) Source B: Dafydd Evans & 64 Tenant Farmers (24 Oct 1843)
1. Who is the audience?
2. What is the writer’s main purpose?
3. What is the overall tone?
4. How does the writer describe the farmers / protesters? (Quote exact phrases) “a lawless midnight rabble of disguised conspirators” and “fanatics”
5. How does the writer describe the toll charges? (Quote exact phrases)

Step 2: Calculate the toll burden and evaluate digital search queries

(a) Use Section 3 of the stimulus sheet. Dafydd Evans has a net weekly income of 10 shillings = 120 pence (120d). Complete the table below to find what percentage of his weekly income goes on road tolls:

Type of journey Toll per gate Total gates per week Weekly cost in pence (d) Percentage of 120d weekly income
(Weekly cost ÷ 120) × 100
1. Two-horse cart of agricultural lime 6d 8 gates
2. Two-horse cart of butter & cheese 9d 2 gates 2 × 9d = 18d (18 ÷ 120) × 100 = 15%
3. Two-horse cart of household coal 8d 3 gates
Combined weekly totals 13 gates Total = ______d Total % = ______%

How many pence out of 120d does Dafydd Evans have left each week to feed and clothe his family after paying 90d in tolls? 120d − 90d = __________d. Does this figure support Colonel Wyndham’s claim that the tolls were a “mere grumble over sixpenny road charges”, or Dafydd Evans’s petition?

(b) Digital sourcing check: Look at Section 4 of the stimulus sheet. Explain why Search 2 ("Rebecca Riots" 1843 ("turnpike" OR "lime") site:library.wales) is a much stronger digital research query than Search 1.

Step 3: Write a two-sided historical explanation

Write a well-structured two-paragraph answer to this question: “Why do Source A and Source B give such contrasting accounts of the 1843 Carmarthenshire protests, and how does the turnpike toll data help a historian judge their claims?”

Step 4: Rewrite a biased sentence for an objective museum website

Colonel Wyndham wrote: “This is no mere grumble over sixpenny road charges; it is seditious terror by a lawless midnight rabble.” Rewrite this in 2 to 3 neutral, objective sentences suitable for a museum display board for Year 9 pupils, including the exact percentage of weekly income spent on lime tolls.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Settling starter: read why Welsh farmers needed lime and what side-bars were.
  2. 5 min Review audience, purpose, tone and vested interest.
  3. 10 min Step 1: compare Sources A and B in the table with direct quotations.
  4. 10 min Step 2: calculate the weekly toll percentages and evaluate the digital search queries.
  5. 12 min Step 3: write your two-paragraph historical explanation.
  6. 5 min Step 4: rewrite Colonel Wyndham’s sentence neutrally and tick the success criteria.
  7. 3 min Plenary: check your calculations and key points against the board.

Success criteria

If you finish early