Cover lesson · Maths · Year 8 · Intermediate

Explaining which phone contract is cheaper

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: literacy in Maths. Pupils write a structured answer to a worded money problem: they say what they are working out at each step, link the steps with words such as so and therefore, and finish with a conclusion that answers the question. The maths (adding and multiplying money) is kept simple on purpose. This prepares pupils for the marks for organising and communicating in GCSE Mathematics and Numeracy (Section 3.1 of the specification).

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Phone contracts for Elin and Osian”, one between two. Calculators are allowed. No computers are needed.

Run: 7 min read the stimulus and do Step 1 · 10 min Step 2, the calculations · 10 min Step 3, marking two answers · 15 min Step 4, writing Elin’s answer · 10 min Step 5, Osian’s problem · 3 min pupils tick the success criteria. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has a model answer. Key numbers: Deal A costs £720, Deal B £723, Deal C £699. Deal C is cheapest but does not suit Elin, so the best answer is Deal A.

What you are doing

Elin needs help choosing a phone deal. Working out the costs is only half the job. The other half is writing an answer that Elin can follow and trust. Today you will read the problem closely, mark two answers from other pupils, and then write your own well-organised answer.

Step 1: read the problem closely

Read sections 1 and 2 of the stimulus. Underline the question Elin asks.

(a) List the facts about Elin that matter when choosing a deal.

(b) List two facts that do not matter. Why can you ignore them?

Step 2: the calculations

(a) Work out the total cost of each deal over 24 months. Numbers only for now.

DealWorkingTotal over 24 months
A
B
C

(b) Which deals give Elin enough data? Which deals can she afford at the start?

Step 3: mark two answers

Read Answer X and Answer Y in section 3. Use the five points in section 4. Write Yes, Partly or No in each box.

A well-organised answer…Answer X (Dylan)Answer Y (Nia)
1. says what is being worked out before each calculation
2. shows every calculation with units
3. puts steps in order and links them
4. ends with a conclusion and a reason
5. checks everything the question says

(b) Both pupils chose Deal C. Why is that the wrong choice for Elin?

(c) Write one piece of advice for Dylan and one for Nia to make their answers better.

Step 4: write Elin’s answer

Write a full answer to Elin. Use your Step 2 working. Use the word bank in section 5. Your answer should have:

Step 5: Osian’s problem

Read section 6. Which deal should Osian choose? Write a full, well-organised answer on your own. Do not look back at Step 4 until you have finished, then check your answer against the five points.

Step by step

  1. 7 min Read the stimulus. Step 1: what matters and what does not.
  2. 10 min Step 2: the totals, data and money at the start.
  3. 10 min Step 3: mark Answer X and Answer Y.
  4. 15 min Step 4: write Elin’s answer.
  5. 10 min Step 5: write Osian’s answer on your own.
  6. 3 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early