Cover lesson · Geography · Year 9 · Intermediate

Holding a meeting on the Pen y Foel quarry extension

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Collaborative talk

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Chwarel Pen y Foel: should the quarry get bigger?”, one per group. No computers are needed. You need a clock or a phone timer.

Groups: groups of 4, 5 or 6. Every group has roles 1 to 4 (Chair, Quarry manager, Resident, Wildlife officer). Add role 5 (Apprentice) in a group of 5, and role 6 (Café owner) in a group of 6. Choose confident pupils as Chairs, or let groups choose.

Run: 6 min Step 1, read the fact file and your own role card · 7 min Step 2, prepare, alone · 5 min Step 3, phrases · 18 min Step 4, the meeting (call out the stages below) · 3 min Step 5, each Chair reports the decision to the class in 30 seconds · 8 min Step 6, reflection, alone · 3 min success criteria. Total 50 minutes.

Call out the stages of Step 4: “Chairs, open the meeting” (1 minute) · “Opening statements, 1 minute each” (6 minutes) · “Open discussion” (8 minutes) · “Chairs, bring the group to a decision” (3 minutes).

Collect: this sheet. The preparation notes, the listening notes, the decision form (Chair’s sheet) and the reflection are the evidence. It is literacy practice: taking a role in a formal group discussion of a local issue and working towards agreement. It builds the skill of weighing up different views that GCSE Geography develops, especially in Unit 4: Sustainable Solutions. This is practice only, not NEA work. The worked example shows what good preparation, notes and reflection look like.

What you are doing

The owners of a quarry want to make it bigger. Your group is a community council meeting that must recommend what should happen. Each of you plays a role with a different view. The aim is not to win: it is for the group to reach the best decision it can.

Step 1: read

Read the fact file and the three options. Then read only your own role card.

My role: ______________________________

Step 2: prepare, on your own

(a) Three points I will make, each backed by a fact from the fact file:

(b) One question I will ask another role, and who I will ask:

(c) A compromise I could accept, even though it is not my first choice:

Chairs only: plan your opening sentence and the order in which people will speak.

Step 3: choose your phrases

Look at the useful phrases on the stimulus. Write one phrase you will use to disagree politely and one you will use to move the group forward. Then write a sentence of your own that builds on what someone else might say.

Step 4: the meeting

Stay in role. Speak one at a time and let the Chair manage the meeting. While others speak, note their main point.

RoleTheir main point

Decision form (Chair fills this in)

Our group recommends Option: ______    Agreed by everyone / by a vote of ______ to ______

Conditions we agreed (Option B only):

The main reason for our decision:

Step 5: report back

Each Chair tells the class the group’s decision and the main reason in 30 seconds. Listen: did other groups decide differently? Note one different idea.

Step 6: reflect, on your own

(a) Score yourself from 1 (not yet) to 3 (confidently) for each of these.

I stayed in roleI used factsI listened and built on othersI disagreed politelyI helped the group move forward

(b) Which moment helped your group get closer to agreement? Who said what?

(c) Out of role now: what do you really think should happen, and why?

Step by step

  1. 6 min Step 1: read the fact file and your role card.
  2. 7 min Step 2: prepare your points, question and compromise.
  3. 5 min Step 3: choose your phrases.
  4. 18 min Step 4: the meeting: opening, statements, discussion, decision.
  5. 3 min Step 5: Chairs report to the class.
  6. 8 min Step 6: reflect on your own.
  7. 3 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early