Cover lesson · History · Year 8 · Intermediate

Hunger marchers in the sources: how reliable is each one?

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Marching from the valleys: three sources on a hunger march, 1936”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need two different coloured highlighters or pencils.

Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 8 min Step 2, fact and opinion · 10 min Step 3, who, when and why · 8 min Step 4, reading between the lines · 7 min Step 5, comparing the sources · 12 min Step 6, writing a paragraph alone. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: reading closely, telling fact from opinion, spotting a writer’s viewpoint and judging how reliable a text is. It prepares pupils for GCSE History, where every unit asks them to analyse and evaluate sources. The three sources are invented; the background is real history.

What you are doing

In November 1936, unemployed men from the South Wales valleys marched to London. You have three sources about the same night in the same English town. They do not agree. Your job is to read each one closely, work out who wrote it and why, and decide which one a historian can trust most.

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read the background box and all three sources. Key words:

Step 2: fact and opinion in Source A

Highlight the facts in Source A in one colour and the opinions in another. Then copy 3 of each.

Facts in Source AOpinions in Source A
1.1.
2.2.
3.3.

Which 2 words or phrases in Source A show most clearly what the writer thinks of the marchers?

Step 3: who, when and why

Who made it? Were they there?When? At the time or later?Why was it made?
Source A
Source B
Source C

Step 4: reading between the lines

(a) Source B was written 50 years after the march. Gwyneth was not on the march. Where do you think her information came from? How might that change the story?

(b) Emlyn writes “Do not worry about me”. Why might he leave some things out of a letter to his wife?

Step 5: compare the sources

How did the people of Kingsford treat the marchers? Write what each source says.

What it says about how the town treated the marchers
Source A
Source B
Source C

Which two sources agree most? Which one disagrees?

Step 6: write a paragraph

In about 120 words, answer: Which source is most reliable for finding out how people in the towns treated the hunger marchers? Use this frame:

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the stimulus with a partner.
  2. 8 min Step 2: highlight facts and opinions in Source A.
  3. 10 min Step 3: who, when and why for all three sources.
  4. 8 min Step 4: reading between the lines.
  5. 7 min Step 5: compare what the sources say.
  6. 12 min Step 6: your paragraph, on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early