Cover lesson · Science and Technology · Year 6 · Advanced

Improving a draft slideshow about circuits

DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content

Also assessed, LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: judging a draft slideshow against success criteria and explaining how to improve its layout and content, using slides printed on paper. Pupils proofread and correct the slide text and explain where and why they made each change, which is real literacy (proofreading, editing and improving) and is marked from the sheet. Science topic: electrical circuits, conductors, insulators and switches.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Nia and Tomos’s draft slideshow: Electricity”, one between two. Colouring pencils are useful for Step 5. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min read “What you are doing” and look at the 4 slides together · 8 min Step 1 · 10 min Step 2 · 12 min Step 3 · 8 min Step 4 · 10 min Step 5 · 5 min Step 6 · 2 min pairs read each other’s feedback. Total 60 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. Proofreading (literacy) evidence is Step 3 (the corrected slide 2 text and the table explaining where and why each change was made) and the corrected sentences in Step 2. Quick checks: the 3 science mistakes are the gap in the slide 2 circuit, plastic and wood called conductors on slide 3, and “open switch, bulb on” on slide 4 (an open switch turns the bulb off).

What you are doing

Nia and Tomos in Year 6 at Ysgol Llan Tywi made a slideshow to teach Year 4 about circuits. It is only a first draft. They have asked you to check it and help them improve it before they show it.

These are the success criteria for the slideshow:

  1. The science facts are correct.
  2. The text is easy to read: big enough and in clear colours.
  3. Spelling and punctuation are correct.
  4. Each picture helps to explain the science.
  5. There are not too many words on the slide.

Step 1: judge each slide

Look at the slides on the stimulus sheet. Put a tick if the slide meets the success criterion, or a cross if it does not.

Success criterionSlide 1Slide 2Slide 3Slide 4
1. The science facts are correct
2. The text is easy to read
3. Spelling and punctuation are correct
4. Each picture helps to explain the science
5. There are not too many words on the slide

Which slide needs the most work? Why?

Step 2: fix the science

There are 3 science mistakes in the slideshow. Find each one and write a correct sentence for Year 4.

SlideThe mistakeCorrect sentence

Step 3: proofread slide 2

Here is the text from slide 2:

you need a cell a bulb and two wires. the circuit has to be a complete loop if their is a gap the electricity cant flow and the bulb wont light

(a) Write it out again with correct capital letters, full stops, commas, apostrophes and spelling. Use 3 sentences.

(b) Explain 4 of your changes: where you made the change and why.

What I changedWhy I changed it

(c) Find the 3 misspelled words on slides 1, 3 and 4. Write each one correctly.

Step 4: improve the layout

For each slide, suggest one change to the layout (size, colour, font, pictures, amount of text) and give a reason that thinks about Year 4 pupils.

SlideChangeReason
1
3
4

Step 5: redesign slide 4

Draw your improved slide 4. Include a title, no more than 2 short correct sentences, and a picture that helps explain how a switch works.

Step 6: give feedback

Write a kind and helpful comment to Nia and Tomos: 2 things they did well and 1 thing to improve. Link each point to a success criterion.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read “What you are doing” and look at the 4 slides.
  2. 8 min Step 1: judge each slide against the success criteria.
  3. 10 min Step 2: find and fix the 3 science mistakes.
  4. 12 min Step 3: proofread slide 2 and explain your changes.
  5. 8 min Step 4: improve the layout.
  6. 10 min Step 5: redesign slide 4.
  7. 5 min Step 6: write your feedback.
  8. 2 min Swap and read a partner’s feedback.

Success criteria for you

If you finish early