Cover lesson · Art · Year 8 · Intermediate

Improving alt text and captions for a school art website

DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content

Also assessed, LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: improving digital content for its audience. An invented Welsh school’s Art department web page shows 6 Year 8 artworks, described in words, with faulty alt text and captions; one breaks the school’s privacy rule. Pupils evaluate, proofread with symbols, rewrite every caption and alt text, and edit the page introduction for parents and visitors. No art is made.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Ysgol Cwm Arian Art department: web page draft”, one per pupil so they can mark it. Pupils need a pen in a second colour and a highlighter if you have them. No computers are needed.

Run: 4 min read the stimulus · 5 min Step 1, what alt text is for · 7 min Step 2, the checklist · 9 min Step 3, proofreading · 6 min Step 4, captions · 10 min Step 5, alt text · 9 min Step 6, the introduction · 4 min Step 7, explain your choices. Total 54 minutes.

Collect: this sheet and the marked stimulus. The quickest check: caption 5 must say Jac, Year 8 with no surname and no “8W2”, and no new alt text should begin “Image of” or “Picture of”. All answers are on the worked example sheet.

What you are doing

Some visitors to a school website cannot see the pictures. Today you are the Art department’s web editor: judge the draft page against a checklist, correct it, and rewrite it so every visitor gets the same information and no pupil’s privacy is put at risk.

Alt text and captions: the facts

Step 1: what are alt text and captions for?

(a) Give 2 situations in which alt text is used.

(b) How is a caption different from alt text?

(c) A screen reader user reaches artwork 1. What do they hear, and what do they miss?

Step 2: evaluate the drafts against the checklist

Write ✓ if the draft meets the point and ✗ if it does not. Row 1 is done for you.

A1 describes what the artwork shows · A2 125 characters or fewer · A3 no file name, “image” or “picture” · A4 does not repeat the caption · C1 caption has title, first name and year group · C2 caption has medium and size · C3 caption spelling, capitals and apostrophes correct · PR no surname or form group anywhere

ArtworkA1A2A3A4C1C2C3PR
1✗✓✗✓✓✗✗✓
2
3
4
5
6

(b) Artwork 1’s alt text is only 10 characters, so it meets A2. Why is it still useless?

Step 3: proofread the captions

(a) Mr Hughes has marked 12 mistakes in captions 1 to 3. Write the correction for each. The first is done for you.

CaptionMarked word or gapSymbolCorrection
1harbourCHarbour
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3

(b) Now be the proofreader. Captions 4 to 6 contain 12 more mistakes. Underline each one on the stimulus sheet and write its symbol after it, as Mr Hughes did. Check every caption against the house style and the art room record.

Mistakes I found: caption 4 ______   caption 5 ______   caption 6 ______   total ______

Step 4: rewrite all 6 captions

Use the house style on the stimulus sheet and every correction from Step 3.

No.Corrected caption
1
2
3
4
5
6

Step 5: rewrite all 6 alt texts

Use the art room record. Start with the main subject, then add the details that matter most, such as colour, mood or what makes the work special. Leave out the title, name and size: they are in the caption. Count the words; if you go over 22, count the characters exactly. The model row is for the example caption on the stimulus sheet.

No.New alt textWords
ModelGrey rain clouds over the flat top of Pen y Fan, green slopes below and a thin path climbing to the summit.22
1
2
3
4
5
6

Step 6: edit the introduction for parents and visitors

(a) Highlight every mistake and every word or phrase that is wrong for the audience in the draft introduction. List 4 things that make the tone wrong for parents and visitors.

(b) What does a visitor need to know that is missing or unclear in the draft?

(c) Rewrite the introduction in 55 to 65 words. Keep it friendly but correct and clear. Keep every true fact; drop the jokes about teachers.

Number of words: ______

Step 7: explain your choices

(a) Why is correcting the capital letter not enough to make caption 5 ready to publish?

(b) Choose 1 alt text you wrote. What did you put first, what did you leave out, and why?

Step by step

  1. 4 min Read the stimulus sheet: the rules, the introduction and the 6 artworks.
  2. 5 min Step 1: read the facts box and answer the questions.
  3. 7 min Step 2: tick or cross the checklist for artworks 2 to 6.
  4. 9 min Step 3: correct the 12 marked mistakes, then find and mark 12 more.
  5. 6 min Step 4: write the 6 corrected captions.
  6. 10 min Step 5: write the 6 new alt texts and count the words.
  7. 9 min Step 6: edit and rewrite the introduction.
  8. 4 min Step 7: explain your choices.

Success criteria

If you finish early