Cover lesson · Maths · Year 9 · Advanced

Interpreting Box Plots and Averages for Broadband Speeds in Wales

LNF: Numeracy → Using data skills → Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: numeracy (interpreting data) and digital data literacy in Maths. Pupils calculate the five-number summary (minimum, lower quartile, median, upper quartile, maximum), range, interquartile range and mean for broadband speeds across 15 homes in a rural Welsh village (Cwm Hafod) and 15 homes in a nearby town (Trefelin). They explain why the interquartile range is fairer than the range when one farm has a 310 Mbps full-fibre line, test 4 broadband claims, and write a precise statistical comparison.

Board: open the supply teacher presentation for board slides, timers and script.

Print: this worksheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Cwm Hafod and Trefelin broadband speed survey and box plots”, one between two. Calculators optional (all sums divide to exact whole numbers).

Run: 5 min starter and read stimulus · 5 min key words · 10 min Step 1, five-number summaries · 10 min Step 2, box plots and outlier analysis · 12 min Steps 3 and 4, test 4 claims and write comparison report · 5 min self-check · 3 min plenary check. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this worksheet. Quick checks: Cwm Hafod: Min = 6, Q1 = 10, Median = 18, Q3 = 26, Max = 310, Range = 304, IQR = 16, Mean = 37 Mbps; Trefelin: Min = 32, Q1 = 44, Median = 56, Q3 = 68, Max = 80, Range = 48, IQR = 24, Mean = 56 Mbps; Claims: A = False/Misleading, B = True, C = True, D = True.

What you are doing

A county council is deciding whether to fund a rural broadband upgrade for the village of Cwm Hafod. Engineers recorded the download speed (in megabits per second, Mbps) at 15 homes in Cwm Hafod and 15 homes in the nearby town of Trefelin. Fourteen homes in Cwm Hafod still use copper telephone lines, while one farm (Hendre Farm) paid privately for a 310 Mbps full-fibre cable. You will calculate the five-number summary and averages for both places, test four claims made in the council meeting, and write an evidence-based comparison report.

Step 1: Order the data and find the five-number summaries

(a) Write the 15 broadband speeds for Cwm Hafod (from section 1 of the stimulus sheet) in order from smallest to largest. Count that you have all 15 values, then circle the 4th, 8th and 12th values.

(b) Complete the summary table below for both locations (Trefelin’s 15 speeds are already in order on the stimulus sheet).

Statistic (in Mbps) How to find it (for n = 15) Cwm Hafod (Mbps) Trefelin (Mbps)
Minimum 1st ordered value
Lower quartile (Q1) 4th ordered value
Median (Q2) 8th ordered value
Upper quartile (Q3) 12th ordered value
Maximum 15th ordered value
Range Maximum − Minimum
Interquartile range (IQR) Q3 − Q1
Mean Total of all 15 speeds ÷ 15

Step 2: Explain why the interquartile range is fairer than the range

(a) If you remove Hendre Farm’s 310 Mbps outlier, what is the range of the remaining 14 homes in Cwm Hafod (from 1st to 14th value)?

(b) Explain why the interquartile range (IQR) is a much fairer measure of spread than the range when comparing Cwm Hafod with Trefelin. Quote both Cwm Hafod’s range and its IQR in your answer.

Step 3: Test 4 broadband claims

Use your table in Step 1 and the box plots on the stimulus sheet to decide whether each claim is True or False / Misleading. Quote the exact statistics that prove your verdict.

Claim Statement made at the council meeting True or False / Misleading? Mathematical proof (quote exact figures)
A “On average, homes in Cwm Hafod get 37 Mbps, so more than half the village enjoys speeds above 35 Mbps.”
B “The middle 50% of broadband speeds in Cwm Hafod are less spread out (more consistent) than the middle 50% in Trefelin.”
C “Every single surveyed home in Trefelin has a faster download speed than at least three-quarters of the homes in Cwm Hafod.”
D “At least a quarter of the surveyed homes in Trefelin receive 68 Mbps or faster.”

Step 4: Write a comparison report for the county council

Write a short, precise paragraph comparing broadband speeds in Cwm Hafod and Trefelin to support the village’s upgrade application. To meet the Year 9 Advanced standard, you must:

  1. Compare the typical speed using the medians (quoting both figures in Mbps).
  2. Compare the consistency of the middle 50% using the interquartile ranges (quoting both figures in Mbps).
  3. Explain why the provider’s mean of 37 Mbps and range of 304 Mbps for Cwm Hafod should not be used.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Answer the starter question and read sections 1 and 2 of the stimulus sheet.
  2. 5 min Review how to find Q1 (4th), Median (8th), Q3 (12th) and IQR (Q3 − Q1).
  3. 10 min Step 1: order Cwm Hafod’s 15 speeds and complete the summary table for both places.
  4. 10 min Step 2: compare Cwm Hafod’s range and IQR with and without the 310 Mbps outlier.
  5. 12 min Steps 3 and 4: judge the 4 claims and write your council comparison report.
  6. 5 min Check that every comparison sentence quotes both statistics and their context.
  7. 3 min Plenary: check your figures against the board.

Success criteria

If you finish early