Cover lesson · PSE / Well-being · Year 8 · Beginner

Is the “best value” gem pack really best value?

LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Logical reasoning

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Draig Dash: the gem shop”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need a calculator.

Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 8 min Step 2, cost per 100 gems · 8 min Step 3, testing the badge · 11 min Step 4, the cheapest way to buy · 8 min Step 5, mystery box claims · 10 min Step 6, writing an argument alone. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is numeracy practice in logical reasoning: testing claims, proving and disproving them with calculations and counter-examples, and explaining a mathematical argument. It supports well-being by helping pupils see how in-game spending can hide real costs. The game is invented. Pupils are not asked how much they spend on games.

What you are doing

Many games sell a made-up currency, such as gems, so that you stop thinking in pounds. You will use maths to test the game’s claims, find the cheapest way to buy what you want, and prove whether statements about mystery boxes are true or false.

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read the whole stimulus sheet, including both boxes at the bottom.

Step 2: cost per 100 gems

To compare packs fairly, work out what 100 gems cost in each pack: price ÷ gems × 100. Round to the nearest penny.

PackGemsPriceCost per 100 gems
Handful100£0.99
Pouch500£4.49
Chest1,100£8.99
Hoard2,400£19.99
Dragon’s Lair6,500£49.99

Check one answer another way: how many gems do you get for £1 in the Chest pack?

Step 3: test the badge

(a) The Hoard pack says “BEST VALUE!”. Is this true? Prove your answer using your table.

(b) A pupil says: “Bigger packs always give you cheaper gems.” Find a counter-example that proves this is false.

(c) Why might a game put a “BEST VALUE” badge on the Hoard pack?

Step 4: the cheapest way to buy

You have no gems. You want the Ember Dragon skin (800 gems).

Way to buyTotal costGems left over
One Chest (1,100 gems)
8 Handfuls
1 Pouch and 3 Handfuls
2 Pouches

(a) Which is cheapest? Is the pack with the cheapest gems (from Step 2) the cheapest way to buy the skin? Explain why not.

(b) Now find the cheapest way to get at least 950 gems for the season pass. Show that you have checked at least three ways.

Step 5: mystery box claims

Write true or false and prove it.

ClaimTrue or false? Proof
1. “If I open 20 boxes, I am certain to get a legendary item.”
2. “I have opened 19 boxes with no legendary, so the next box is almost certain to be legendary.”
3. “20 boxes cost 3,000 gems, which is about £25.” (Use the Chest price per 100 gems.)

Step 6: write an argument, on your own

Your younger cousin wants to buy the Hoard pack “because it is best value” to get the Ember Dragon skin. Write them a short message (about 80 words) that proves, with numbers, what they should do instead. Use at least one of: because, so, therefore, this proves.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the stimulus with a partner.
  2. 8 min Step 2: cost per 100 gems.
  3. 8 min Step 3: test the badge.
  4. 11 min Step 4: the cheapest way to buy.
  5. 8 min Step 5: mystery box claims.
  6. 10 min Step 6: write your argument, on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early