Cover lesson · Geography · Year 11 · Advanced

Judging bias in sources about a honeypot village

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Llanfeuno: five sources on a honeypot village”, one per pupil if possible, because pupils annotate it. No computers are needed. Pupils need a calculator, a pen and 2 highlighters or coloured pencils.

Run: 8 min Step 1, reading for purpose · 8 min Step 2, fact, opinion and bias · 8 min Step 3, reliability · 8 min Step 4, checking claims with data · 15 min Step 5, extended answer, alone and in silence · 3 min success criteria. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: reading several sources closely, telling evidence from bias, judging reliability and bringing sources together to reach a judgement. It prepares pupils for AO3 in GCSE Geography (analysing and evaluating a variety of sources) and for the source skills in Unit 4, Section 4.2.2. This is examination-style practice only, not NEA work. A model answer and all answers are on the worked example.

What you are doing

Five sources describe how tourism has changed an invented Welsh village. They do not agree. You will work out what each source is for, spot bias, test claims against data and write a balanced answer that uses the sources as evidence.

Step 1: read for purpose

Read all five sources. For each one, fill in the table.

SourceWho wrote it?PurposeOverall view of tourism (positive, negative, mixed, neutral)
A
B
C
D
E

Step 2: fact, opinion and bias

(a) On the stimulus, highlight facts in one colour and opinions in another in Sources A and B.

(b) Copy 3 words or phrases from Source A that show bias. Say what makes each one biased.

(c) Copy 2 phrases from Source B that are emotive. What effect do they have on the reader?

(d) What does Source D reveal without meaning to?

Step 3: how reliable is each source?

Give each source a score from 1 (not reliable) to 5 (very reliable) and a reason. Think about vested interest, balance and evidence.

SourceScoreReason
A
B
C
D
E

(b) Source C has data, but read its notes. Give one reason why even Source C might not be completely reliable.

Step 4: check the claims against the data

Use Source C to test each claim. Calculate the percentage change where you can (change ÷ 2015 value × 100).

ClaimWhat Source C shows (with a calculation)Accurate, exaggerated or wrong?
A: “Visitor numbers have nearly doubled.”
A: “Jobs in tourism have risen by almost half.”
B: “One in three houses is now a holiday home.”
B: “House prices have nearly doubled.”
B: “The school has lost half its children.”

(b) Which fact in Source C does neither A nor B mention, but supports what Sources D and E say about parking?

Step 5: extended answer

“To what extent has tourism been good for Llanfeuno? Use evidence from the sources.”

Plan first: one paragraph on benefits, one on problems, then a conclusion with your judgement. Quote or use data from at least 3 sources. Say how reliable a source is when you use it, for example “Source A claims ..., but as it was written by the business group, ...”. Write about 250 words.

Step by step

  1. 8 min Step 1: read all 5 sources for purpose and view.
  2. 8 min Step 2: fact, opinion and bias.
  3. 8 min Step 3: score each source for reliability.
  4. 8 min Step 4: test 5 claims against the data.
  5. 15 min Step 5: plan and write your extended answer, on your own.
  6. 3 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early