Cover lesson · IT · Year 11 · Advanced

Judging online reports of a data breach

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: reading critically. Pupils read three invented online sources about a data breach at a leisure centre: the centre’s own statement, a local news report and a viral social media post. They compare the details, separate facts from opinions and unsupported claims, analyse loaded language, judge each source’s reliability, and write an extended answer. GCSE Digital Technology asks pupils to judge the reliability of online information and to write extended answers in the Unit 1 examination.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “The Llynwen Leisure Centre data breach: three online sources”, one per pupil if possible (pupils quote line numbers). Highlighters help. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min Step 1, skim · 8 min Step 2, scan and compare · 8 min Step 3, fact, opinion or claim? · 7 min Step 4, loaded language · 8 min Step 5, reliability · 14 min Step 6, extended answer, alone and in silence. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. Checks you can make: Source C says 10,000 people and bank details; Sources A and B say 2,400 and no bank details. Source C was posted on 13 March, one day after the centre says it discovered the breach, yet claims the centre “knew for weeks”.

What you are doing

When something goes wrong online, people read about it in many places at once. Some sources are careful, some are angry and some have something to protect. You will decide how far each source can be trusted, using evidence from the texts.

Step 1: skim for the gist

Read all three sources quickly. Sum up each one in no more than 12 words.

SourceGist
A
B
C

Step 2: scan and compare

Find what each source says. Write the line number. Write “not stated” if it says nothing.

 Source ASource BSource C
How many people?
What information?
When was it found?
What should members do?

Step 3: fact, opinion or claim?

Label each statement F (a fact that could be checked), O (an opinion) or U (a claim with no evidence given). Explain one of your choices below the table.

LineStatementF, O or U
2We closed the system within two hours.
7We take the security of your information extremely seriously.
12I only noticed because the web address was spelt wrong.
13The centre told the Leader it had not sent any refund emails.
18EVERYONE’s bank details stolen, my mate says it’s 10,000 people.
19They KNEW for weeks and said NOTHING.
21Typical, useless, can’t even run a swimming pool.

Step 4: loaded language

(a) Quote 3 words or phrases from Source C chosen to make readers feel angry or scared. What is the effect of the capital letters and exclamation marks?

(b) Source A also chooses its words carefully. Quote one phrase that is designed to reassure members, and explain why the centre might want to reassure them.

(c) Is Source B’s headline fair? Use the word “hack” in your answer.

Step 5: reliability

 Source ASource BSource C
Who wrote it, and would they know?
Why was it written?
Evidence given or corroborated?
Possible bias

Step 6: extended answer

On your own, in silence. Answer the question in 180 to 220 words:

“How far can each source be trusted about what happened at Llynwen Leisure Centre?”

Include: a judgement on each source; at least 3 short quotations with line numbers; one place where two sources corroborate each other; one place where they disagree and which you believe; and a conclusion that ranks the sources.

Help: Source A is useful because ... However, the centre has a reason to ... · Source B is more balanced, as shown by ... · This is corroborated by ... · Source C claims “...”, but ... · Overall, the most reliable source is ... because ...

Step by step

  1. 5 min Skim each source and write its gist.
  2. 8 min Scan for details and compare them.
  3. 8 min Sort statements into fact, opinion and unsupported claim.
  4. 7 min Analyse the loaded language.
  5. 8 min Judge each source’s reliability.
  6. 14 min Write your extended answer on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early