Cover lesson · Integrated Science · Year 11 · Advanced

Linking a balanced evaluation of bus fuels

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: literacy in Integrated Science. Pupils use connectives and a mix of simple, compound and complex sentences to link evidence into a balanced evaluation that reaches a decision: should a council run its buses on hydrogen or bioethanol? This is the skill in Appendix B of the GCSE Integrated Science (Single Award) specification: “evaluate personal, social, economic and environmental implications of science and make decisions based on the evaluation of evidence and arguments”. Analysing, interpreting and evaluating (AO3) is 25% of the qualification. It is examination practice, not NEA.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Hydrogen or bioethanol? Evidence cards for Cyngor Bro Cynon”, one between two. No calculators or computers are needed.

Run: 6 min Step 1, sorting connectives · 8 min Step 2, filling the gaps · 10 min Step 3, joining sentences · 8 min Step 4, diagnosing Tomos’s answer · 18 min Step 5, the extended answer · 5 min Step 6, checking and redrafting. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has every answer and a model evaluation. There is no single right decision: pupils are marked on how well they link and weigh the evidence.

What you are doing

In the GCSE examination, a list of true facts does not get top marks. The marks go to answers that link each fact to a consequence, compare the two options and end with a decision that follows from the evidence. Connectives are the words that do that linking. Today you will practise them, then use them in a full evaluation.

Step 1: sort the connectives

Write each connective in the right column. Use section 4 of the stimulus to check.

whereas · as a result · furthermore · on balance · although · similarly · therefore · in addition · however · consequently · overall · both · on the other hand · moreover · this means that

AddingContrastingCause and effectComparingConcluding

Step 2: fill the gaps

Choose the best connective for each gap from this box. Use each one once.

however · therefore · in addition · overall · so · for example

Bioethanol is made by fermenting sugar from crops, (1) ______________ wheat. The crops take in carbon dioxide as they grow; (2) ______________, burning the fuel adds less new carbon dioxide to the air than burning diesel. (3) ______________, farming and transporting the crops uses energy, (4) ______________ bioethanol is not completely carbon neutral. (5) ______________, land used for fuel crops cannot grow food. (6) ______________, bioethanol is a partial solution rather than a complete one.

Step 3: join the sentences

Join each pair into one sentence using the connective given. You may change the order and a few words, but keep the meaning. Say whether your new sentence is compound or complex.

Two simple sentencesUseYour sentence
(a) Hydrogen buses produce only water at the exhaust. Diesel buses produce carbon dioxide and nitrogen oxides.whereas
(b) Most hydrogen is made from natural gas. Hydrogen buses are not always low-carbon.because
(c) Hydrogen can be made using wind power. It currently costs more.although
(d) The council would need to build a filling station. The switch would cost more at first.as a result
(e) Converting a bus to bioethanol is cheap. The fuel can be delivered to the existing depot.furthermore

Step 4: what is wrong with Tomos’s answer?

Read Tomos’s first attempt in section 6. Every sentence is true.

(a) What kind of sentence has he used every time?

(b) Give two reasons why his answer would get low marks, even though the facts are right.

(c) Rewrite his first three sentences as one or two linked sentences that explain why each fact matters.

Step 5: the extended answer

Question: Cyngor Bro Cynon wants to cut carbon dioxide and improve air quality. Evaluate whether it should switch its buses to hydrogen or to bioethanol. Use the evidence cards and give a reasoned judgement. [6 marks]

Plan: paragraph 1 on hydrogen (a benefit, a problem and what it means); paragraph 2 on bioethanol (the same); paragraph 3, your decision with a reason that refers back to the council’s two aims. Use at least one connective from every column in Step 1, and quote card numbers in brackets, for example (H2).

Step 6: check and redraft

(a) Circle every connective in your answer. How many are there? Which column is missing, if any?

(b) Find one simple sentence in your answer and rewrite it as a complex sentence that explains a consequence.

Step by step

  1. 6 min Step 1: sort the 15 connectives.
  2. 8 min Step 2: fill the 6 gaps.
  3. 10 min Step 3: join 5 pairs of sentences.
  4. 8 min Step 4: diagnose and improve Tomos’s answer.
  5. 18 min Step 5: write the 6-mark evaluation.
  6. 5 min Step 6: check, redraft one sentence and tick the success criteria.

Success criteria

If you finish early