Cover lesson · RE · Year 9 · Intermediate
LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening as part of collaborative talk
Name: Class: Date:
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “A wind farm on Mynydd Garnedd? Discussion cards”, one per group. No computers are needed.
Organise: groups of four, sitting so that pairs can face each other. Give each pupil a letter: A, B, C or D. A group of five can have a third observer.
Run: 6 min pupils read the stimulus in their groups · 4 min Step 2, choosing listening phrases · 8 min Round 1: A and B talk, C and D observe (call time) · 8 min Round 2: C and D talk, A and B observe (call time) · 12 min Round 3: all four agree a decision · 12 min Step 6, reflection alone. Total 50 minutes. Walk round and listen; remind pupils to use the phrases in Step 2.
Collect: this sheet. The observer log (Steps 3 and 4), the group decision (Step 5) and the reflection (Step 6) are the evidence. It is literacy practice in listening as part of a discussion: responding to others with questions and comments, agreeing and disagreeing with reasons, and working towards a compromise. It prepares pupils for GCSE Religious Studies, where they discuss contentious issues and weigh different perspectives. The place and people are invented; the belief cards are real teachings. Pupils are not asked to share their own religious beliefs.
A company wants to build a wind farm on a hill that some people see as holy. Good discussion is not taking turns to say your own opinion: it is listening and building on what others say. Today you will be judged on how well you listen, not on how loudly you argue.
Read the situation, the four local voices and the belief cards together as a group.
Tick three phrases you will try to use. You must use at least one from each column during the lesson.
| Building on | Agreeing or disagreeing | Asking |
|---|---|---|
| ☐ Adding to what ... said, ... ☐ That links to ... because ... ☐ So what you are saying is ... | ☐ I agree with ... because ... ☐ I see your point, but ... ☐ I disagree, because ... | ☐ Why do you think that? ☐ What would happen if ...? ☐ What should happen next? |
A and B discuss question 1 on the stimulus for 6 minutes. C and D each watch one speaker (C watches A, D watches B) and tick every time they hear the behaviour. In the last 2 minutes, the observer tells their speaker one thing they did well and one thing to try next.
Observer log (fill in when you are an observer in Round 1 or Round 2):
| Listening behaviour | Ticks |
|---|---|
| Builds on what the other person said | |
| Asks a question about reasons (why?), results (what would happen if?) or next steps | |
| Agrees or disagrees and gives a reason | |
| Sums up what the other person said before replying | |
| Interrupts or ignores what was just said |
Best example I heard (write the words):
Swap. C and D discuss question 2 for 6 minutes. A watches C, B watches D, using the observer log above. Then 2 minutes of feedback.
When I was a speaker, my observer said I did well at:
and should try next:
Discuss question 3. Rule: before anyone makes a new point, they must first respond to the last speaker, using a phrase from Step 2. Try to reach a decision everyone can accept, even if it is a compromise.
| Our group decision | |
|---|---|
| The main reason | |
| What we changed or gave up to agree | |
| A view in the group that was different |
(a) Write down something another person in your group said that made you think again. Who said it and what was it?
(b) Did it change or strengthen your view? Explain in 3 or 4 sentences, referring to at least one belief card.
(c) Which listening phrase helped your group most? Why?