Cover lesson · English · Year 10 · Intermediate
LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening to understand
Name: Class: Date:
What this practises: listening to understand. Pupils hear two opposing speeches read aloud by a partner, record what they hear on a notes grid, then work out how each speaker presents a one-sided viewpoint (selecting figures, loaded language, leaving things out), judge which information is relevant and significant, and reach their own reasoned conclusion. This is practice for GCSE English Language and Literature Unit 3 (Section 3.2), where pupils discuss how speakers and texts try to influence an audience and respond to other people’s views. It is practice only, not assessed work. The town, the speeches and all the figures are invented.
Print: this sheet, one per pupil (2 pages). The stimulus sheet “The Pontarddu Library debate: two speeches”, printed single-sided, one set of 2 pages between two. No computers are needed.
Run: pupils work in pairs, Pupil A and Pupil B (make one group of 3 if needed: the third pupil listens to both speeches and reads nothing). 3 min set up: sort pairs, give out the speeches face down, pupils read “What you are doing” · 6 min Step 1: Pupil A reads Speech 1 aloud twice, Pupil B listens and fills in Grid 1 · 6 min Step 2: swap, Pupil B reads Speech 2 aloud twice, Pupil A listens and fills in Grid 2 · 8 min Step 3, compare notes, then turn both speeches face up and check · 8 min Step 4, how each speaker presents a viewpoint · 6 min Step 5, relevance and significance · 14 min Step 6, reasoned conclusion, in silence. Total 51 minutes. Nobody turns to page 2 of this worksheet until Step 3 (b), because it quotes the speeches. In Step 6, tell the class when 5 minutes are left.
Collect: this sheet. The notes grids (Steps 1 and 2) and the conclusion (Step 6) are the evidence.
Quick checks: Speech 1 (the councillor) uses the fall in visits from 98,000 in 2015 to 61,000 last year; Speech 2 (the campaigner) uses the rise from 54,000 to 61,000 in the last 2 years. Both can be true. The councillor leaves out that staffed hours fall from 38 to 20, that books fall from 22,000 to 9,000, and the bus problem. The campaigner leaves out the £640,000 repair bill, the £90,000 yearly saving and the longer opening hours. In Step 6, a secure conclusion is about 150 words, uses at least 3 figures, names one bias technique from each speaker and states a clear view. A model is in the worked example.
The council wants to move Pontarddu Library out of the town centre and into the leisure centre, with self-service machines. You will listen to two speeches about the plan, one for and one against, read aloud by your partner. You will not see the words while you listen. You will note what you hear, work out how each speaker tries to win you over, decide which information really matters, and then write your own conclusion.
Key words:
Decide who is Pupil A and who is Pupil B. Pupil A takes page 1 of the stimulus sheet (Speech 1). Pupil B takes page 2 (Speech 2). Keep your speech face down until it is your turn to read.
Short notes only. Write every figure with what it is about (for example: “200: free parking spaces”).
Grid 1: Speech 1, Councillor Meirion Howells (for the move)
| Listen for | My notes |
|---|---|
| Main points (at least 3) | |
| Figures and what each one is about | |
| Loaded or emotive words and phrases | |
| What did the speaker not tell me? What would I ask? |
Grid 2: Speech 2, Bethan Rowlands, Friends of Pontarddu Library (against the move)
| Listen for | My notes |
|---|---|
| Main points (at least 3) | |
| Figures and what each one is about | |
| Loaded or emotive words and phrases | |
| What did the speaker not tell me? What would I ask? |
(a) Using only your notes, tell your partner the main points and figures of the speech you heard (2 minutes each). While your partner talks, fill in the first 2 rows of the grid you have not done yet.
(b) Now turn both speeches face up. Check both grids against the speeches. Correct any figure you got wrong in a different colour, and add 2 loaded words to the grid you filled in from your partner.
I caught ____ figures correctly by ear. The figure I missed or got wrong was:
(a) Complete the table. Use short quotations or figures.
| Technique | Speech 1: the councillor | Speech 2: the campaigner |
|---|---|---|
| Selection: which visit figures does each speaker choose? | ||
| Loaded language: 2 examples, and what each makes you feel | ||
| Omission: one important thing the other speaker mentions but this one leaves out | ||
| A claim with no evidence, or evidence that is weak | ||
| Who does the speaker say they speak for? |
(b) Both speakers give true figures about visits, but one says visits are falling and the other says they are rising. How can both be true?
For each piece of information, write Y or N: is it relevant to whether the library should move? Then rate how significant it is: H (high), M (medium) or L (low), and give a short reason.
| Information | Relevant? Y or N | H, M or L | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. The library building opened in 1910. | |||
| 2. The building needs £640,000 of repairs over 10 years. | |||
| 3. The leisure centre has free parking for 200 cars. | |||
| 4. There is 1 bus an hour to the leisure centre, and none on Sundays. | |||
| 5. In an online survey, 7 out of 10 people said they would use a library open in the evenings. | |||
| 6. Staffed hours would fall from 38 to 20 a week. | |||
| 7. Bethan Rowlands has used the library since she was 5. |
Question: Having listened to both speakers, should Pontarddu Library move to the leisure centre?
Write about 150 words. Weigh up both speeches. Use at least 3 figures you heard, name one way each speaker presents a one-sided view (selection, loaded language or omission), and end with a clear conclusion. You may say what extra information you would need, or what would change your mind. Spend 2 minutes planning in the box, then write.
You could use: The councillor wants us to believe... but leaves out... · The campaigner makes us feel... by... · The most significant point is... because... · On balance, I think...