Cover lesson · Music · Year 11 · Advanced

Planning a reflective log for a composing brief

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: planning and organising extended writing in Music. Pupils take an invented pupil’s messy composing notes, sort them by purpose instead of by date, cut what the reader does not need, write topic sentences and a paragraph plan, then write a structured reflective log of about 250 words. The WJEC GCSE Music composing unit includes a reflective log, so this builds a skill they need. It is practice only, not NEA work: pupils write about Gwion’s invented piece, not their own composition, so no supervision rules apply. Nothing needs to be played.

Print: this sheet and the stimulus sheet “Gwion’s composing notes and the brief for Ar y Llwybr”, one of each per pupil. Pupils need a pen and a highlighter if you have them.

Run: 5 min read the stimulus · 10 min Step 1, sort the notes, in pairs · 7 min Step 2, topic sentences · 8 min Step 3, paragraph plan · 17 min Step 4, write the log, alone and in silence · 3 min Step 5, check. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has a model plan and a model log.

What you are doing

Gwion’s notes are in the order things happened. A good reflective log is organised by purpose: what he aimed for, what he decided and why, how he used feedback, and how well the piece meets the brief. You will turn a diary into a clear, reasoned piece of writing for a teacher who has never heard the music.

Step 1: sort the notes

Read every note (N1 to N19). Write each note number in one row. Some notes are useful in two places: put them where they help most.

Section of the logNote numbersWhat this section must answer
A. IntentionWhat was he aiming for, and why?
B. Decisions and reasonsWhat did he choose, and how does each choice fit the brief?
C. Response to feedback and testingWhat did others or tests show, and what did he change?
D. Evaluation against the briefDoes it meet each point of the brief? What would he improve?
Leave outWhy does the reader not need these?

Why is it better to organise the log by purpose than by session (Session 1, Session 2 …)?

Step 2: topic sentences

A topic sentence tells the reader the point of the paragraph. Compare:

Weak: In session 2 I did some changes. (no point, no reason, diary order)

Strong: Feedback showed me that my tune was too busy for a podcast, so I rebuilt the middle section around the presenter’s voice. (a clear point that links to the brief)

Write a strong topic sentence for each section.

SectionTopic sentence
A. Intention
B. Decisions
C. Feedback
D. Evaluation

Step 3: paragraph plan

For each paragraph, note the evidence you will use (numbers, musical details, quotations) and a connective or phrase that links it to the next paragraph.

 Evidence and reasons (short notes)Link to the next paragraph
A
B
C
D(a precise conclusion)

Useful phrases: My aim was to … · I chose … because … · This suited the brief, which asked for … · As a result, … · However, … · In response, I … · When I tested it, … · The final version … · Overall, … · With more time, I would …

Step 4: write Gwion’s reflective log

On your own, in silence. Write as Gwion, in the first person, about 250 words (220 to 280) in 4 paragraphs. Use your plan. Use real detail from the notes: numbers, chords, instruments and people’s comments. Do not write about your own composition.

Step 5: check

Tick each box that is true for your log. Then improve one sentence and write the new version below.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the brief, the notes and the task. Highlight anything linked to the brief.
  2. 10 min Step 1: sort the notes into sections, in pairs.
  3. 7 min Step 2: write 4 topic sentences.
  4. 8 min Step 3: plan each paragraph.
  5. 17 min Step 4: write the log on your own.
  6. 3 min Step 5: check and improve one sentence.

Success criteria

If you finish early